Stop Linking the Sydney Siege to IslamStop Linking the Sydney Siege to Islam
















Time.com


Subscribe




Sign In
Sign Out




Home


U.S.


Politics


World


Business


Tech


Health


Science


Entertainment


Newsfeed


Living


Sports


History


The TIME Vault


Magazine


Ideas


Parents




Money


LIFE


The Daily Cut





Photography



Videos




Person of the Year 2014
Top 10 Everything of 2014
Next Generation Leaders
Above and Beyond
Human Data
Know Right Now
The Nantucket Project
New Energy Reality
Retirement Redefined
TIME 100
TIME Explains
Top of the World








Subscribe
Newsletters
Feedback
Privacy Policy
Your California Privacy Rights
Terms of Use
Ad Choices 


RSS
TIME Apps
TIME for Kids
Media Kit
Advertising
Reprints and Permissions
Site Map
Help
Customer Service
© 2015 Time Inc. All rights reserved.























Rihanna Wins Legal Battle Against U.K. Store Topshop Over Use of Her Image





See Yemen’s Tumultuous History in Pictures






Hunt for Impartial Jurors Delays Boston Bombing Trial





Seattle to Begin DNA Testing on Backlogged Rape Kits





Who Is Saudi Arabia’s New King?





Rich Nation, Poor People: Saudi Arabia by Lynsey Addario






Romney Faces Doubts From 2012 Donors





New Orleans Bans Smoking in Bars and Casinos





King Abdullah’s ‘Special Relationship’ With the U.S.





Saudi King Abdullah Dies at 90


 
SCROLL TO SEE MORE












TIME
World
Australia

Stop Linking the Sydney Siege to Islam




Ian Lloyd Neubauer


Dec. 16, 2014


SHARE






 
  



Visitors look at a makeshift memorial near the scene of the fatal siege in the heart of Sydney's financial district on Dec. 16, 2014. Sydneysiders including tearful office workers and Muslim women in hijabs laid flowers at the scene in an outpouring of grief and shock
Peter Parks—AFP/Getty Images


The perpetrator was not a jihadist but a criminal described by his own lawyer as "damaged goods"
If the location of the Sydney siege — images of which flashed around the world for 16 hours before two hostages and a gunman were killed — appeared familiar, it’s because Martin Place is a popular international film set. Superman Returns and the Matrix trilogy were filmed in the pedestrianized, central Sydney precinct, lined with colonial-era buildings that are the headquarters of Australia’s largest financial institutions, law firms and broadcasters as well as high-end retailers like Brooks Brothers and the Lindt Chocolat Café, where the tragedy took place.
MoreWatch Non-Australians React to the Taste of Vegemite PizzaHundreds of Asylum Seekers Are on Hunger Strike Over Australia’s Resettlement PlanBaker Faces Complaint for Refusing Anti-Gay Order NBC NewsPill-Popping Mommas: 'Many' Pregnant Women Use Opioids NBC News'It's So Cool!': Sidecar Dogs Make Easy Riders NBC NewsWhat is absolutely alien, on the other hand, is that nature of a man like the 50-year-old Iranian-born perpetrator, Man Haron Monis. There is no point in trying to place him, as some have attempted, in an overarching discourse of Islamist terrorism and history, because he was plainly not a terrorist but a mentally disturbed individual and serial sex offender. Neither is it helpful to describe this tragedy — as media mogul Rupert Murdoch did — as a “wake-up call” for the nation, because, from the Port Arthur massacre to the Bali bombings, Australia has had plenty of those already.
Popular Among Subscribers


Interstellar, Where No Movie Has Gone Before

Subscribe
The Last Men of SteelReview: Interstellar’s Wonder of Worlds BeyondTo be sure, Monis lost a final appeal in the High Court to overturn a conviction he had received for sending hate mail to the widows of Australian troops killed in Afghanistan. So much, so jihadist. But he was also a pervert (facing 40 charges of sexual assault) and accused of being an accessory to the murder of his ex-wife. That makes him more criminal than terrorist. As everyone now knows, he couldn’t even get his props right: the black flag he forced his hostages to hold in the window of the café was not the emblem of the Islamic State of Iraq and Greater Syria (ISIS) but a plain and simple shahada — a common Muslim inscription that says “There is no god but Allah and Muhammad is the messenger of Allah.” Unable to furnish his own, Monis had to demand an ISIS flag from the authorities in exchange for a hostage. He never got it.
It’s true that Australia has been expecting a terrorist attack. Security assets have been high alert since September when ISIS called for members to seek retribution against Australia and other members of the coalition it is fighting in the Middle East. Clive Williams, professor at Macquarie University’s Department of Policing, Intelligence and Counter Terrorism, also concedes that Monis’ deranged last stand “had some of the characteristics of a terror attack — it was religiously motivated, designed to terrorize and directed towards noncombatants.” But, he stresses, “the thing that was lacking was strategy. It was an irrational act of violence and it is not clear what he hoped to achieve.”
He adds: “It seems more of a reaction to the problems he was experiencing in the criminal justice system. The one thing that will probably come out of this that we need to look at how we manage people with mental-health issues.”

Williams sentiments were echoed by Keysar Trad, the founder of the Islamic Friendship Association of Australia and voice for Sydney’s Lebanese Muslim community: “I am hoping that all Australians will see this for what it is: the actions of a madman.”
Australia’s long-suffering asylum seekers, thousands of whom remain cruelly holed up in indefinite detention in offshore detention centers in third-world backwaters, may be fearing some backlash. Monis arrived in Australian in 1996 as a political exile. Abdul Numan Haider, a teenage terrorist suspect who was shot dead in Melbourne in September after attacking two police officers with a knife, arrived in Australia as a refugee with his parents a decade ago.
The Refugee Council of Australia (RCOA), however, has refused to entertain suggestions that the Australian government will clamp down even harder on refugees. “I don’t think there is any point speculating,” an RCOA spokesperson tells TIME. “It’s not something we are talking about.”
Greg Barton of the Global Terrorism Research Centre also talks the idea down. “I don’t think it makes sense to relate this event to Australia’s migration policy, except to say that people coming from troubled backgrounds are vulnerable to further trouble themselves. We need to reach out to them more and engage with them rather than simply seizing their passports,” he says of the dozens of Australian Muslims who’ve had their travel documents seized over fears they intend to join the 150-odd Australian jihadists fighting in Syria and Iraq.
Monis may have sympathized with those fighters and he may have been inspired by them to a degree. But trying to make sense of a lunatic killer described by his own lawyer as “damaged goods” is an exercise in futility. He could just as easily have cloaked himself in the guise of any number of radical causes to help generate media coverage.
In that sense, Monis has not changed Australia forever but the opposite: he has brought out what was always there. Take a look at the #IllRideWithYou social-media hashtag, used to express solidarity with Australians Muslims fearing the scapegoating and bigotry that invariably follows events like this. In that gesture of support is the spontaneous generosity and the tolerance and the ready compassion that is forever Australian.




0













0





 



 


HOME


U.S.


POLITICS


WORLD


BUSINESS


TECH


HEALTH


SCIENCE


ENTERTAINMENT


NEWSFEED


LIVING


IDEAS


PARENTS


SPORTS


HISTORY


THE TIME VAULT


MAGAZINE


NEWSLETTERS


Advertising


Media Kit


SITE MAP


© 2015 Time Inc. All rights reserved.
Powered by WordPress.com VIP




				Sign In
				



					Not a memeber? Sign Up







								Oops! We didn't recognize your email or password. Please try again.
							

Existing Subscriber


EMAIL





PASSWORD





SIGN IN




Remember Me /
									Forgot Password? /
									Create Login





Want the Full Story?
SUBSCRIBE







Your browser, Internet Explorer 8 or below, is out of date. It has known security flaws and may not display all features of this and other websites.
Learn how to update your browser

TAP


U.S. Edition



U.S. Edition


Europe, Middle East and Africa Edition


Asia Edition


South Pacific Edition



 















 





