
Charlie Hebdo: Norway's Christians didn't have to apologise for Anders Breivik, and it's the same for Muslims now - Comment - Voices - The Independent

Charlie Hebdo: Norway's Christians didn't have to apologise for Anders Breivik, and it's the same for Muslims now - Comment - Voices - The Independent














































Friday 23 January 2015















Apps 




eBooks 




i Jobs 




Dating 




Shop 





































News 



Video 





People 





Voices 



Find by writer 





Yasmin Alibhai-Brown 




Rebecca Armstrong 




Memphis Barker 




Max Benwell 




Chris Blackhurst 




Ian Burrell 




Andrew Buncombe 




Ben Chu 




Patrick Cockburn 






Mary Dejevsky 




Grace Dent 




Robert Fisk 




Andrew Grice 




Stefano Hatfield 




Lucy Hunter Johnston 




Howard Jacobson 




Alice Jones 




Ellen E Jones 






Simon Kelner 




Lisa Markwell 




Michael McCarthy 




Hamish McRae 




Jane Merrick 




James Moore 




Matthew Norman 




Dom Joly 




Amol Rajan 






John Rentoul 




Steve Richards 




Deborah Ross 




Kim Sengupta 




Joan Smith 




Mark Steel 




Janet Street-Porter 




John Walsh 




Andreas Whittam Smith 







Comment 




Editorials 




Letters 




IV Drip 




Campaigns 





Homeless Veterans 




Save the tiger 




Elephant Campaign 




Equal Partners 




Delayed Diagnosis 




We are Malala 




Child Soldiers 




Voices in Danger 




The New Suffragettes 






Rory Peck Awards 




British Citizen Awards 







Archive 




Our Voices 





Rentoul 




The Editors 




The Foreign Desk 




Battle of Ideas 







Commentators 





Yasmin Alibhai-Brown 




Terence Blacker 




Simon Carr 




Rupert Cornwell 




Sloane Crosley 




Mary Dejevsky 




Robert Fisk 




Andrew Grice 




Adrian Hamilton 






Philip Hensher 




Howard Jacobson 




Dominic Lawson 




John Lichfield 




Campaigns 




Hamish McRae 




Matthew Norman 




Christina Patterson 




John Rentoul 






Steve Richards 




Sarah Sands 




Mary Ann Sieghart 




Joan Smith 




Mark Steel 




Campaigns 




Janet Street-Porter 




Andreas Whittam Smith 




Voices 







Columnists 





Dom Joly 




David Lister 




Thomas Sutcliffe 




John Walsh 




Janet Street-Porter 




Chris Bryant 







Democracy 2015 




IV Drip Archive 




Blogs 




Scottish independence 




Save the tiger 




The state of the NHS 








Sport 



Tech 





Life 





Property 





Arts + Ents 





Travel 





Money 





IndyBest 





Student 



Offers 




Hot Topics

Page Three
Chilcot inquiry
Homeless Veterans Campaign






















 
Mark Steel




Follow






Thursday 8 January 2015




Charlie Hebdo: Norway's Christians didn't have to apologise for Anders Breivik, and it's the same for Muslims now




It's as if no one in any Western country has ever gone berserk with a gun in a public place before























 




















Share







The important thing must be to establish the rules, so we can all get along. To start with, are you allowed to be critical of Muhammad at all? For example, can you suggest that while he was generally perfect, he could sometimes be quite forgetful, and wander into Mecca saying "what did I come out here for"?




If you say "he was the best prophet going, but I have to be honest and say he was shit at table tennis", does that warrant an execution or just a wallop with some pebbles?
And are all images banned, as there seems to be some confusion over this? Maybe there’s a moderate wing of Islamic State, that says it’s alright as long as he’s drawn from the left as that shows off his best side.












Can you draw him if his face isn’t revealed, like the band Slipknot, or The Stig? There should be an agreed and written code, as the stakes for getting it wrong seem to be fairly high.
I suppose the one comfort we can take from this week’s events, is that some of us are lucky enough to live in a society based on Western values, because in countries like America you can’t imagine a lunatic ever going berserk with a gun in a public place.
READ MOREFollow the Paris shootings live'One million copies' of Charlie Hebdo to be be published#JESUISCHARLIE HASHTAG USED ACROSS THE WORLDOne way in which we’re ensuring we protect those values, is by demanding all Muslims denounce the gunmen. It’s true that every Muslim leader in Britain has denounced them several times, but that’s hardly sufficient. They might denounce them at five past three, and then again at twenty past three, but what are they doing in between? For all we know they’re blowing themselves up at bus garages.
So to truly distance themselves from the shooting, every Muslim should have to draw their own satirical cartoon involving Muhammad trampolining on a pig, so we know we can trust them.
Similarly, when the Norwegian Christian Anders Breivik committed his massacre, all decent people marched straight down to the church and yelled "oy vicar, why haven’t you issued a statement condemning the shooting"? And politicians insisted Special Branch must infiltrate every C of E jumble sale to prevent similar radical movements growing throughout Surrey.
When Newcastle gunman Raoul Moat went crazy, I’m sure I remember interviewers, callers on phone-in shows and website forums insisting it was up to so-called moderate Geordies to denounce these atrocities, and X Factor started that week with Louis Walsh saying he wouldn’t take part unless Cheryl Cole condemned this "foul evil act of pure foul evil, carried out by her own people".



Police hunt for Raoul Moat in 2010

Nigel Farage has concluded the murders in Paris prove there’s a “fifth column” seeking to destroy us from within, adding “On a cultural level, what price anybody who is a stand-up comic, a cartoonist, a newspaper columnist, who wants to say something critical about Islam at all?”
This is a fair point, because it’s hard to think of a single newspaper that at any time has ever said anything critical about Islam isn’t it? The Daily Mail for example is virtually a tabloid version of The Koran, and reading The Sun is like watching a Bin Laden video with added tits.

In pictures: Reaction to Charlie Hebdo attack
Out in rural Kent, where Nigel Farage is standing to be MP, it’s just Allah Allah Allah all day long. You try buying a buttered scone in Broadstairs during Ramadan.
The claim that Farage and many others appear to make is that Islam is inevitably violent, to which others reply that it’s a religion of peace, with each side quoting chunks of religious text to make their case. But this probably doesn’t help to settle the argument, as every religion’s holy book is a chaotic mixture.
The Old Testament is like an episode of The Sopranos written by someone on crack, with prophets murdering children for calling them "baldhead" and nations destroyed with locusts. But most of us can pass a church without thinking "we should deport those loonies, they want to turn you into a pillar of salt".
Because Christianity can be interpreted in any way you like. You can be a Christian and believe that means you should be generous, peaceful, modest and love thy neighbour. Or you can be a Christian and be a Tony Blair. There’s room for everyone.
The same could be true of all faiths, its followers ranging from the heroic to the despicable, all of them justifying their actions by finding the relevant quote in their holy text. So the most logical response to any supposedly religious act is to respond to the act and not the religion.
But there is one other possibility that’s been overlooked. Maybe the murderers are confused by the British government’s attitude towards crazy Islamic gunmen, which has appeared inconsistent.
Not long ago President Assad of Syria, whose record for madness and violence is exemplary, was invited by the Prime Minister to stay at Buckingham Palace. And the rulers of Saudi Arabia, who recently got through 19 executions in one month, are sold billions of pounds worth of weapons. So maybe the gunmen’s strategy was to prove how mental they were, thinking they’d then be invited for biscuits with The Queen, and then be asked to do a deal for a tank.  
READ MOREFrance was gripped by tension even before the shootings'MY COUNTRY’S WORST NIGHTMARE HAS COME TRUE'








React Now


















Tweet




 

 


























The Daily Cartoon









Enter URL:



Enter URL:





















donatenow
read aboutour appeal


























Please provide search keyword(s)












Advanced search 




Article archive 




Topics 


























New



Hot



Commented








Voices



Isis conference: International co-operation can only work if all the key players are invited, and that means Russia









Voices



Greece is not the only country where the euro vision has fast become a nightmare









Voices



What is Prince Andrew doing in Davos anyway?









Voices



Give Chilcot a break – he’s probably still working on his inquiry into the Battle of Hastings









Voices



Is ‘zero suicides’ an ambitious enough target?















Mass prescription of statins ‘will widen social inequalities’	


Charlie Cooper




Coalition's tax and benefits changes hit low income families harder than any other group	


Andrew Grice



























independent images







Tel Aviv bus attack






Ravensbrück concentration camp






World's best bargain hotels






State of the Union






No More Page Three campaign






Stunning macro images






World news in pictures






UK news in pictures






Arts + Ents news in pictures 






Sport news in pictures





< Previous
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Next >















SPONSORED FEATURES








i100: How to take a wild career break and come back more employable

Fancy a wacky sabbatical?

 
Gambia


i100


Gym for free




RICS


Prizes & offers


Business videos






A warm welcome to the smiling coast of Gambia

The Gambia is fast becoming known as a winter sun haven

 
Wild Career Break


i100


Gym for free




RICS


Prizes & offers


Business videos






i100: Who makes your world a better place?

Tweet us the people who deserve some recognition to @thei100 with the hashtag #everydayhero and tell us why.

 
Wild Career Break


Gambia


Gym for free




RICS


Prizes & offers


Business videos






Turn Blue Monday Red

On officially the most depressing day of the year, Fitness First opens its doors to everyone for free. Get energised, focused and upbeat.

 
Wild Career Break


Gambia


i100




RICS


Prizes & offers


Business videos






Build yourself a brighter future

Chartered surveyors will be critical to shaping our new world

 
Wild Career Break


Gambia


i100




Gym for free


Prizes & offers


Business videos






Enter the latest Independent competitions 

Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.

 
Wild Career Break


Gambia


i100




Gym for free


RICS


Business videos






Business videos from commercial thought leaders

Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.

 
Wild Career Break


Gambia


i100




Gym for free


RICS


Prizes & offers


















More FromMark Steel




Give Chilcot a break – he’s probably still working on his inquiry into the Battle of Hastings






What a perfect tribute to satire the Paris march turned out to be






At last Cuba is free to become more like the glorious US of A!






Food banks: Don’t you people know how to make a banquet out of bugger all?






Nativity plays: Don’t be silly, of course the talking sheep and pregnant virgin are real




















iJobs General



Ashdown Group: Marketing Executive - London - £32,000

£28000 - £32000 per annum:
Ashdown Group:
Marketing Executive - East London - ...


Recruitment Genius: IS Network Field Engineer

Negotiable:
Recruitment Genius:
We are offering an excellent opportunity to jo...


Recruitment Genius: Telesales Consultant - OTE £28,000

£14000 - £16000 per annum:
Recruitment Genius:
A Telesales Advisor is sought t...


Recruitment Genius: Cook

Negotiable:
Recruitment Genius:
A Cook is required to work in a care home sett...





View the latest from iJobs






Day In a Page





Sun
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat





1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31


January
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December


1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015

Go









 











Read Next



 
Isis conference: International co-operation can only work if all the key players are invited, and that means Russia


Mary Dejevsky















 
Greece is not the only country where the euro vision has fast become a nightmare


Peter Popham


























Ex Machina: Machine vs man Alex Garland's film explores the limits of artificial intelligence - but how close are we to machines outsmarting man? 






50th anniversary of Winston Churchill's death There are many events marking 50 years since the statesman's death ... and some are more tasteful than others 






'Truly terrible prospects await' Doomsday Clock nears midnight as scientists warn we're as close to destruction as we were during the Cold War 






Action this day! Homeless Veterans open trading at the London Stock Exchange 






Out of puff: Cigarette advertising The government wants cigarettes to be in plain packs, but Big Baccy won't be the only loser 








Dinosaurs were killed by cold, not heat Giant asteroid unlikely to have created firestorms big enough to kill off dinosaurs, scientists say 






Fancy dinner in the kitchen? The hottest restaurant tables now put diners right in the thick of the action 






Making the normal abnormal Radicalising menswear is a tough job in Paris, which lacks the male fashion traditions of a place like London 






Step up: The 10 best women's trainers Want shoes you can wear with everything? We find on-trend treads to see you through spring 






Paul Scholes column Raheem Sterling is a major asset for Liverpool, even if he isn't always the greatest striker of the ball 








Free-for-all transfer 'utopia' will be another step back for Premier League The Arsène Wenger model of producing better academy footballers in order to solve the declining number of native players is unrealistic, says Sam Wallace 






Frank Warren's Ringside Music mogul Al Haymon calls tune with Deontay Wilder 






An old hand at work in the Yemen's bloody civil war The US now appears anxious to crush the Houthi rebels and their Sunni al-Qaeda enemies - and the Saudis would have it no other way, reports Robert Fisk 






Homeless Veterans appeal Boris Johnson pledges £200,000 in major boost to campaign 






Islam should grant the freedom to question The West's best hope of dealing with the rise of Islamic extremism is to challenge the doctrines manufactured by religious scholars past and present, argues Ziauddin Sardar 































Terms & Policies 



Privacy Policy 



Cookie policy 



Code of Conduct 



Complaint form 



Email newsletters 



RSS 



Live Blogs 



About i100 







Contact Us 



Subscriptions 



Apps 



Work for us 



Evening Standard 



Homes & Property 



iJobs 



News video 



Sport video 







Advertising Guide 



Syndication 



Novaya Gazeta (English) 



ES Business Connections 



ES Rentals 



London Live 




© independent.co.uk



























Please provide search keyword(s)












Advanced search 




Article archive 




Topics 































