Martin Place cafe siege: Overreaction from fear is a measure of a terrorist's successMartin Place cafe siege: Overreaction from fear is a measure of a terrorist's success
Skip to navigation
Skip to content
Help
        using this website - Accessibility statement



JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.


My News 


My Clippings 


My Comments 


My Benefits 




Today's Paper


Subscribe


Log in


Register

Personalise your news, save articles to read later and customise settings





If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

 

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.



 










2:27PM Friday Jan 23, 2015
    27192(0) online now

Do you know more about a story?

contact us

Close

Provide detailed information, including contact details (if relevant)









Real Estate
Cars
Jobs
Dating
Newsletters


Fairfax Media NetworkMore

Close


News & Weather

smh.com.au
theage.com.au
brisbanetimes.com.au
canberratimes.com.au
nationaltimes.com.au
watoday.com.au
weatherzone.com.au



Business & Finance

businessday.com.au
brw.com.au
afr.com
afrmagazine.com.au
smartinvestor.com.au
investsmart.com.au



Lifestyle

life & style
dailylife.com.au
thevine.com.au
essentialbaby.com.au
essentialkids.com.au
findababysitter.com.au
goodfood.com.au



Classifieds

domain.com.au
drive.com.au
adzuna.com.au
rsvp.com.au
stayz.com.au






Advertise with us
Newsletters
Full list of sites
About Fairfax Media
Privacy
Terms & Conditions
















The Sydney Morning Herald


Comment



Letters



Editorials



Column 8



Obituaries



View from the Street



Blunt Instrument




You are here: Home Comment 



Search smh:



Search in:


Comment



smh.com.au
Web
Comment












Martin Place cafe siege: Overreaction from fear is a measure of a terrorist's success



Date


                December 16, 2014




(29)

Read later









Peter Hartcher
Sydney Morning Herald political and international editor

View
                            more articles from Peter Hartcher











Tweet





submit to reddit
Email article

Print


Reprints & permissions














Return to video
Video settings
Please Log in to update your video settings


Video will begin in 5 seconds.

Don't play
Play now



More video
Recommended




Martial arts meets philosophy for aikido women




Shark tagging expedition off Qld coast




Scott Morrison's political bromance 




Belinda's story: a policeman's suicide




Coral trout found off Sydney





Replay video



Return to video
Video settings
Please Log in to update your video settings


Watch: moment Sydney siege ended
Hostages run for their lives, then police storm the Lindt cafe, with gunfire echoing up Martin Place.
PT1M36S

620
349

Autoplay OnOff
Video feedback
Video settings




Martin Place siege - Live updates on day two
Sydney cafe siege over as gunshots fired
Separating fact from fiction
What the Islamic flag means
#illridewithyou hashtag goes viral
When I chanced to walk through Martin Place a little after 11am on Monday, I saw the police clustered closely around the Lindt Cafe. I saw the police cordon as I stood among some hundreds of onlookers.The police evidently had the situation in hand. The crowd was curious, but might as well have been watching a busker for all the tension in the air. Some onlookers snapped photos. Some left as others arrived. The scene was perfectly calm.

                                Crowds told to move on from Martin Place on Monday morning.  Photo: Peter Rae


It was only when I turned on the TV an hour or so later that I realised the magnitude of our dimwittedness. We were supposed to be terrified.
Advertisement


The Prime Minister led in shaping our responses. He called a press conference but had no information to offer on the incident except that he had held a meeting to discuss it. He took only one question, to explain that he had no details but that the NSW police did. "We don't yet know the motivation of the perpetrator," he said, then freely speculated that he was politically motivated. It was "very disturbing".

                                Heavily armed police in Martin Place.  Photo: Daniel Munoz


And if the family and friends of the hostages in the café were not already worried enough, Abbott announced that "I can think of almost nothing more distressing, more terrifying, than to be caught up in such a situation."A stampede of politicians, State and federal, took to the airwaves to tell us how to feel. The incident was "horrifying" said Bill Shorten. Attempting a Churchillian gravitas, the opposition leader declared that "Australians are shocked, but won't be shaken."But it was the State premiers who most clearly illustrated the paradox that governed political reaction: The further from the incident, the greater the distress.Victoria's Daniel Andrews declared that it was a "terrifying incident". He gravely assured Victorians that the gunman in Martin Place posed no known threat to the people of Victoria.Queensland's Premier Campbell Newman ordered "all available police out there" to "protect Queenslanders".The reaction of most media for most of the day was to cheerlead the hype and to provide a ready platform to any politician who wanted to insert himself into the event. Meanwhile, in Sydney, public transport was rerouted, buildings kilometres away were shut down and school excursions throughout the city cancelled. In all, hundreds of thousands of Sydneysiders were affected.Why do political activists turn to terrorism? Australia gave the world a lesson today. They turn to terrorism to win attention, to cause fear, and to use that fear to produce an overreaction. That overreaction is the measure of their success.Terrorism is a tool of the weak against the strong. It is designed to turn the enemy's strength against itself. One man showed how to get extraordinary attention and inflict serious disruption using only a gun and a Muslim prayer banner.Successful terrorism is so rare in Australia that the overreaction is perhaps understandable. The police response seemed exactly right. But our political and media systems need to get better at measured reaction. Abbott said on Monday evening that the incident had been "profoundly shocking". He added: "I think I can also commend the people of Sydney for the calmness with which they have reacted". With no help from the politicians.

















Tweet





submit to reddit
Email article

Print


Reprints & permissions










Advertisement





Related Coverage




Watch: moment Sydney siege ended






                Most popular
            



1




Mutterings in unhappy Tony Abbott ranks – is ...


Contains:
total comments542




2




The black plague of finance: easy money not seen ...


Contains:




3




A day with Myuran Sukumaran, a remarkable artist ...


Contains:




4




Australia doesn't have a problem with alcohol. We ...


Contains:




5




We all have our inner fascist: why it's important ...


Contains:













Featured advertisers










   <!-- UI NOTE: Make iframed content accessible: -->
   <a href="http://assets.betterbills.com.au/widgets/SMH-NSW.html">View these special offers by BetterBills.</a>







LATEST VIDEO

Featured  Videos More video




Martial arts meets philosophy for aikido women
Hundreds of aikido students from around the world gather in Melbourne for an intense week of training to mark 50 years of the sport in Australia, ahead of a demonstration in Fed Square on Saturday. 
PT4M7S

300
169
Thu Jan 22 22:33:10 UTC 2015





Click to play video

Newman promises 2654 health workers" 




Click to play video

Shark tagging expedition off Qld coast" 




Click to play video

Boy found after parents murdered" 













Advertisement









Real Estate



Inside Michael Clarke's home

Domain.com.au
Buy real estate
How much is my house worth?
FREE Property Newsletter




Jobs



Find your perfect job today

Adzuna.com.au
What is Adzuna?
Where are all the jobs?
Jobs blog




Essential Baby



16 times 'dad reflexes' saved the day

Essentialbaby.com.au
Due Date Calculator
Baby names
Ovulation calculator




Relationships



Australia's Favourite Dating Site

Rsvp.com.au
Chat Online With Singles
Online Dating
Meet New RSVP Members




Find A Babysitter



Get before and after school care organised now

Findababysitter.com.au
Sydney Child Care
Canberra Child Care
Port Macquarie Child Care






Compare and Save

Skip to:

Best Deals
Mobile
Broadband
Home Loans
Credit Cards
Low Rate Cards
Rewards Cards
Savings Accts
Money Deals
Loans


Check out today's best deals

0% p.a. for 16 Months

Enjoy a low rate on balance transfers. Conditions apply

Find Out More


Need a Personal Loan?

No monthly fees + no penalties for early repayments

Find Out More


Boost your Savings

Compare savings accounts from leading lenders today

Compare Now


iPhone 6

We compare all carriers and deals

Compare Deals


Deals for 2015

Switching networks or staying, we compare it

Compare Deals























Readers' most viewed

Most viewed articles on Brisbane TimesTop 5 Comment articles


Campbell Newman lied about Stradbroke Island mining promises


Too many questions over Newman


Campbell Newman is lying to you, and he knows it


Mutterings in unhappy Tony Abbott ranks – is mutiny on the horizon?


Jeff Seeney makes me hot




Most viewed articles on WA TodayTop 5 Comment articles


Mutterings in unhappy Tony Abbott ranks – is mutiny on the horizon?


A day with Myuran Sukumaran, a remarkable artist who won't give up in the face of bleak destiny


Sad surfer boy: how growing up at Perth beaches shaped a wave-riding career


Australia Day 2065 won't be on January 26 


Burqa ban a political excuse for persecution




Most viewed articles on The AgeTop 5 Comment articles


We might see first-class plays at the Malthouse now


Mutterings in unhappy Tony Abbott ranks – is mutiny on the horizon?


A day with Myuran Sukumaran, a remarkable artist who won't give up in the face of bleak destiny


Our desperate need for better infrastructure


Australia Day 2065 won't be on January 26 




Most viewed articles on Canberra TimesTop 5 Comment articles


Mutterings in unhappy Tony Abbott ranks – is mutiny on the horizon?


Public stewardship needs a new rationale


A day with Myuran Sukumaran, a remarkable artist who won't give up in the face of bleak destiny


Trams are outdated  


CFMEU, like everyone else, must perform its job within the law




Most viewed articles on The Sydney Morning HeraldTop 5 Comment articles


Australia Day 2065 won't be on January 26 


Mutterings in unhappy Tony Abbott ranks – is mutiny on the horizon?


Australia doesn't have a problem with alcohol. We have a problem with violence


A day with Myuran Sukumaran, a remarkable artist who won't give up in the face of bleak destiny


 Reality bites as Team Abbott loses shine









SMH Home


NSW


Politics


World


National


Environment


Business


Digital Life


Entertainment


Life & Style


Travel


Cars


Exec Style


Sport


Weather





Sydney Morning Herald


Sitemap


About Us


Contact Us


Advertise with Us


AM Today


Last 8 days


Text Version


Site Accessibility Guide





Connect


Mobile Site


SMH for iPad


Digital Edition


RSS


Facebook


Twitter


LinkedIn





Products & Services


Subscribe


Manage My Subscription


My Benefits


Good Food Guide


SMH Shop


Newsletters


Cracka Wines





Classifieds


Place an Ad


Accommodation


Cars


Dating


Jobs


Property Price Data


Real Estate


Buy and Sell


Tributes


Celebrations


Special Reports





Fairfax Media


Member Centre


Conditions of Use


Privacy Policy


News Store Archive


Photo Sales


Purchase Front Pages


Fairfax Syndication


Fairfax Events


Fairfax Careers


Press Council













Fairfax Media

Our Sites


The Sydney Morning Herald


The Age


Adzuna


Domain


Drive


RSVP


Essential Baby


InvestSMART


APM


Stayz


Weatherzone


TheVine

Our Partners


Buy & Sell


Cruises


Lawyers


Credit Cards


Business


Mechanics


Electricians


Fitness


Hair Salons


Weddings


Home Builder


Cracker


Copyright © 2015 Fairfax Media











































































