  Police Shadow Journalists’ Charlie Hebdo Gathering in Beijing - China Real Time Report - WSJ  Police Shadow Journalists’ Charlie Hebdo Gathering in Beijing - China Real Time Report - WSJ












WSJ

WSJ
Facebook
Twitter

 
 


MarketWatch

MarketWatch



Barrons

Barrons





Product X

Product X









djx


rt


f


r&c


pe&vc


wsj


b






The Shops

The Shops



More


New Portfolio


Big Charts


Virtual Stock Exchange


WSJ Asia

WSJ India 

								  

WSJ China 

									  chinese edition


WSJ Japan 

									  japanese edition





WSJ Europe


WSJ Americas

en Español 

								  

em Português

								  




WSJ Radio


WSJ Wine









					SEARCH
				











		
			
			
			
				
					
						
							headline
						
						
							
							goldman
							
						
					
				
				
					
						
							Companies
						
						
							
							
								GOLD
							
							
								Ran
								gold Resources Ltd. ADS
							
							
								U.S.
							
							
						
					
				
			
			
				
					
						View All Search Results »
					
				
			
			
			
		
	




 

The Wall Street Journal





Welcome, 
Logout


My Account
My Journal
Help
Message Center ( new)






Log In
Register
Subscribe Now











U.S. Edition



                            WSJ.com is available in the following editions and languages:
                        




                                        U.S.
                                         




                                        Asia
                                         




                                                India
                                                 




                                                China  
 






                                        Europe
                                         




                                    	Americas
                                    



                                                en Español
                                                 




                                                em Português
                                                 











Login/Register to set your edition
                        		





Set my edition








Today's Paper

Video
Columns
Blogs
Topics
Journal Community




Register for FREE


Register for FREE


Thank you for registering.
We sent an email to: 
Please click on the link inside the email to complete your registration


 


Please register to gain free access to WSJ tools.

An account already exists for the email address entered.
Forgot your username or password?


This service is temporary unavailable due to system maintenance. Please try again later.


The username entered is already associated with
another account. Please enter a different username


The email address you have entered is already in use.Please re-enter the email address.







First Name





Last Name




Email Address





Create a User Name




Create a Password





Confirm Password

  


Send me information about more WSJ features


Create a profile for me in the Journal Community



 

 

Why Register?
Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions

As a registered user of The Wall Street Journal Online, you will be able to:

Setup and manage your portfolio
Personalize your own news page
Receive and manage newsletters


 
 
 
 
 

Log In

Log In



User Name



Password



Log in



Remember me
Forgot your password?


























Culture
Chinese Communist Party Warns Officials: Calligraphy Isn’t for Amateurs


Economy & Business
What the Fu? Backlash for Burberry Over Chinese Scarf Design
 
MarketsEconomy & BusinessLaw & PoliticsTechnologyEnvironment & HealthCulture  Change Language:       English           中文（简体） 中文（繁體)     中文（简体） 中文（繁體)   
Hot Topics:
Pollution

Media

Reform

Communist Party

Censorship

Disputed Territory

MH370

China Econtracker
 












                3:52 pm  HKTJan 9, 2015        

Law & Politics 

          Police Shadow Journalists’ Charlie Hebdo Gathering in Beijing        






Article


Comments (49)





BeijingCensorshipjournalistsMediapolicepress freedom 




















Journalists hold signs saying “I am Charlie” in French and Chinese on Thursday night at the Bookworm cafe and bookstore in Beijing.
Wang Zhao/Agence France-Presse


Foreign correspondents who gathered at a Beijing bookstore on Thursday night to show support for the victims in this week’s deadly attack on a French satirical magazine came under close police scrutiny, though they were allowed to go ahead with plans to take a group photo.
The Foreign Correspondents’ Club of China is one of several media groups worldwide that have released photos on social media of members holding placards that read “I am Charlie” in French and other languages after Wednesday’s Paris attack on Charlie Hebdo magazine that killed 12 people and wounded several others.
The irreverent magazine, which was also firebombed in 2011, has published cartoons depicting Islam, Muslim clerics and the Prophet Mohammad. The groups’ photos are intended as a show of solidarity with the magazine’s employees and of defiance toward the masked gunmen’s apparent attempt to chill free speech.Advertisement
FCCC President Peter Ford said he saw approximately a half dozen apparent plain clothes policemen in the crowd of over 100 foreign and Chinese reporters, including one who videotaped everyone in attendance. At least two uniformed police were also visible in the packed main room of the Bookworm and at the building’s entrance. The manager of the bookstore and café could not be reached.
Beijing’s Public Security Bureau did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Friday.
“I assume the authorities were nervous about something they might have perceived as pro-freedom of speech in a gathering that could’ve had implications for China,” Mr. Ford said. “But the purpose of the meeting was exclusively to express our sympathy for the families of the victims and others, support for the organization and our outrage at the murder of people whose opinion the attackers disagreed with.”
Photos of club members holding blue and white “I am Charlie” signs in French and Chinese were distributed on Twitter, Facebook and in an email to members.
Scrutiny of Thursday’s event, attended by China Real Time, comes amid heightened anxiety in Beijing over the influence of Western political ideas.  China in recent months has jailed or detained dozens of rights activists and lawyers, launched probes into the activities of foreign nonprofits and issued warnings through state media about the risk of “foreign forces” destabilizing the nation.

More In Media

Charlie Hebdo Attack Shows Need for Press Limits, Xinhua Says
China Military Paper Submits 'Proof' West Point Paid Homage to Lei Feng
Taking a Stand: Resurrection Awaits for Hong Kong’s Pro-Democracy House News 
China No. 1 for Jailed Journalists, Group Says
China on Ferguson Violence: 'There's No Such Thing As Perfection' 



China in 2014 ranked 175 of 180 countries in a press freedom index compiled by the activist group Reporters Without Borders, two notches below its 2013 ranking. The FCCC said in a September position paper that foreign journalists in China, their staff and sources have seen a notable increase in threats and violence since the 2008 Beijing Olympics.
The FCCC holds regular happy hours and meetings featuring guest speakers typically without attracting overt attention from the police. Some members said this event may have attracted scrutiny because it was also attended by Chinese media, possibly raising concern that the publicity could encourage local activism.
“This does touch on a sensitive issue, press freedom and freedom of expression,” said Ruth Kirchner, a China correspondent for the German ARD broadcasting group, who attended at the gathering. “They might be worried that people will use this issue with China.”
Mr. Ford, the FCCC president, said he tried to explain what the group was doing to an apparent plain clothes policeman to avoid any misunderstanding but the man declined to say whether or not he was linked to the Public Security Bureau. “He said he wasn’t interested in what we were doing, so we went ahead,” Mr. Ford said, adding that he didn’t tell the Bookworm in advance of the planned photo opportunity. “It slipped my mind,” he added.
Johnny Erling, a Beijing-based correspondent with German daily newspaper Die Welt, said Chinese police also may have been on high alert following Shanghai’s New Year’s Eve stampede that killed 36 people and injured at least 49.
“They’re really scared when there are lots of people now, that could be the most important thing,” Mr. Erling said. “They should know from our information that this has nothing to do with China.”
– Mark Magnier. Follow him on Twitter @markmagnier. 
Sign up for CRT’s daily newsletter to get the latest headlines by email.
For the latest news and analysis, follow @ChinaRealTime
 



Recommended post x
Buy in the Morning, Carry a Bottle: WSJ Reporters’ Advice for Traveling in China




 
















China Real Time Report HOME PAGE 


 












  

Search China Real Time Report1




  Expert Insight   previous pause next    A New Ray of Hope in China's Fight Against Pollution: Lawsuits New legal developments that help environmental non-profits sue polluters now offer some hope for those fighting the degradation of China’s ecosystem.   Beijing's Concern Grows Over Anti-Corruption Critics  There appears to be mounting concern in the Chinese Communist Party about resistance to Xi Jinping's anti-graft crusade, raising the possibility Beijing could extend its crackdown to target  officials who are insufficiently loyal.   What It Will Take for China’s Anticorruption Drive to Succeed As 2015 dawns, a key task facing the party is to combine legal reforms with anticorruption efforts in such a way that China can finally break free of the culture of graft that underpins public cynicism about the country’s leaders.   After the 'Shock and Awe': China's Anti-Corruption Quagmire Stories out of central China's Henan province highlight a major challenge for Chinese President Xi Jinping’s anticorruption crusade: to not only to halt graft but also--once malfeasance is contained--to prevent it from reappearing.   China's Corruption Fight Inseparable from Economic Reform It remains to be seen whether China's aggressive anti-graft drive can pave the way for the extensive economic reforms that the party has committed to pursue. If not, corruption will continue to plague China for the foreseeable future.  


About China Real Time Report

RSS



China Real Time Report is a vital resource for an expanding global community trying to keep up with a country changing minute by minute. The site offers quick insight and sharp analysis from the wide network of Dow Jones reporters across Greater China, including Dow Jones Newswires’ specialists and The Wall Street Journal’s award-winning team. It also draws on the insights of commentators close to the hot topic of the day in law, policy, economics and culture. Its editors can be reached at chinarealtime@wsj.com.



China Real Time Report on Twitter


 China Real Time Report on Facebook




Most RecentArticlesComments
1.
How China’s New Foreign Investment Rules Might Play Out


2.
China Asks Officials to Stop Plagiarizing Their Self-Criticisms


3.
‘Shameless, Uncreative, Dreadful’ Chinese Movies Vie to Be the Worst in Competition


4.
China’s Communist Party Sounds Death Knell for Arrest, Conviction Quotas


5.
$129,000 for Shanghai Stampede Victims Draws Debate Online


1.
desperado

China Asks Officials to Stop Plagiarizing Their Self-Criticisms		
6 Comments



2.


How A Single Chinese Character Weighs in Deciding Shanghai Stampede Blame		
1 Comment



3.
_jiao

‘Shameless, Uncreative, Dreadful’ Chinese Movies Vie to Be the Worst in Competition		
6 Comments



4.


China Gets More Brazen About Its Ambitions for the Yuan		
10 Comments



5.
Ian

China’s Communist Party Sounds Death Knell for Arrest, Conviction Quotas		
6 Comments




China RealTime Report

RSS







        James Areddy
      
      Shanghai
    



        Laurie Burkitt
      
      Beijing
    




        Te-Ping Chen
      
      Hong Kong
    



        Josh Chin
      
      Beijing
    




        Jason Chow
      
      Hong Kong
    



        Bob Davis
      
      Beijing
    




        Chao Deng
      
      Shanghai
    



        Eva Dou
      
      Taipei
    




        Esther Fung
      
      Shanghai
    



        Wei Gu
      
      Hong Kong
    




        Brittany Hite
      
      Beijing
    



      Jenny Hsu
      
      Taipei
    




        Charles Hutzler
      
      Beijing
    



      William Kazer
      
	  Beijing
    




      Wayne Ma
      
      Beijing
    



        Dinny McMahon
      
      Beijing
    




        Colum Murphy
      
      Shanghai
    



      Jeremy Page
      
      Beijing
    




      Richard Silk
      
      Beijing
    



        Brian Spegele
      
      Beijing
    




      Carlos Tejada
      
      Beijing
    



        Chuin-Wei Yap
      
      Beijing
    







close

Email This







								Recipient's Email Address (Separate multiple address with commas)






								Your Email Address
							




								Message (Optional)






								Send me a copy
							






or Cancel












close

Thank You
Your email has been sent.









close

Error.
An error has occured and your email has not been sent. 
			  	Please try again.
			  	





• Invalid email address.
• You can't enter more than 20 emails.
• Seperate multiple addresses with Commas.
• Must enter an email address.
• You must enter the verification code below to send.
• Invalid entry: Please type the verification code again.



Popular Now
What's This?

Close
Content engaging our readers now, with additional prominence accorded if the story is rapidly gaining attention. Our WSJ algorithm comprises 30% page views, 20% Facebook, 20% Twitter, 20% email shares and 10% comments.





1


'American Sniper'


Twitter


Facebook


Email


Comments




2



Where Are America's Millionaires?


Twitter


Facebook


Email


Comments




3



Windows 10: How It Works on Laptops and Tablets


Twitter


Facebook


Email


Comments




4



The State of the Economy, in Eight Charts


Twitter


Facebook


Email


Comments




5



Don’t Lose Sleep Over Proposed Tax Boosts


Twitter


Facebook


Email


Comments


Show 5 More






6



The Patriots’ Deflategate Controversy - The Short Answer


Twitter


Facebook


Email


Comments




7



GE Earnings: What to Watch


Twitter


Facebook


Email


Comments




8



Poll Finds Agenda Gap Between Leaders, American People


Twitter


Facebook


Email


Comments




9



Obama Takes Aim at 'Step Up' Tax Break on Inherited Assets


Twitter


Facebook


Email


Comments




10



Citigroup Shareholders Could See a Windfall


Twitter


Facebook


Email


Comments


Show Less




  









WSJ Web Slice
CONTENT
LINKS TO ACTUAL PAGE CONTAINING WEB SLICE FUNCTIONALITY.

15





Wall Street Journal
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
FourSquare
Google+
YouTube
Podcasts
RSS Feed
AppStore


Subscribe
/Login 


Back to Top«




Customer Service

Customer Center
New! Live Help

Contact Us
WSJ Weekend
Contact Directory
Corrections



Policy

Privacy Policy
 Cookie Policy
Data Policy
Copyright Policy
Subscriber Agreement& Terms of Use
Your Ad Choices



Advertise

Advertise
Place a Classified Ad
Sell Your Home
Sell Your Business
Commercial Real Estate Ads
Recruitment & Career Ads
Franchising
Advertise Locally



Tools & Features

Apps
Emails & Alerts

Graphics
Columns
Topics
Guides
Portfolio
Old Portfolio



More

Why Subscribe
Register for Free
Reprints

Content Partnerships
Conferences

Price & Volume
Keyword & Symbol
News Archive
Jobs at WSJ







Copyright ©2014 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
















close

Email This







								Recipient's Email Address (Separate multiple address with commas)






								Your Email Address
							




								Message (Optional)






								Send me a copy
							






or Cancel












close

Thank You
Your email has been sent.









close

Error.
An error has occured and your email has not been sent. 
			  	Please try again.
			  	





• Invalid email address.
• You can't enter more than 20 emails.
• Seperate multiple addresses with Commas.
• Must enter an email address.
• You must enter the verification code below to send.
• Invalid entry: Please type the verification code again.



