Sydney siege: inside the terrifying hostage drama Sydney siege: inside the terrifying hostage drama 
Skip to navigation
Skip to content
Help
        using this website - Accessibility statement



JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.


My News 


My Clippings 


My Comments 


My Benefits 




Today's Paper


Subscribe


Log in


Register

Personalise your news, save articles to read later and customise settings





If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

 

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.



 










2:19PM Friday Jan 23, 2015
    27605(0) online now

Do you know more about a story?

contact us

Close

Provide detailed information, including contact details (if relevant)









Real Estate
Cars
Jobs
Dating
Newsletters


Fairfax Media NetworkMore

Close


News & Weather

smh.com.au
theage.com.au
brisbanetimes.com.au
canberratimes.com.au
nationaltimes.com.au
watoday.com.au
weatherzone.com.au



Business & Finance

businessday.com.au
brw.com.au
afr.com
afrmagazine.com.au
smartinvestor.com.au
investsmart.com.au



Lifestyle

life & style
dailylife.com.au
thevine.com.au
essentialbaby.com.au
essentialkids.com.au
findababysitter.com.au
goodfood.com.au



Classifieds

domain.com.au
drive.com.au
adzuna.com.au
rsvp.com.au
stayz.com.au






Advertise with us
Newsletters
Full list of sites
About Fairfax Media
Privacy
Terms & Conditions
















The Sydney Morning Herald


NSW



NSW News



Sydney Traffic



NSW State Election 2015



Quizzes




You are here: Home NSW News 



Search smh:



Search in:


NSW



smh.com.au
Web
NSW












Sydney siege: inside the terrifying hostage drama 



Date


                December 18, 2014




243 reading now
(29)

Read later









Deborah Snow
Senior writer

View
                            more articles from Deborah Snow


Follow Deborah
                        on Twitter
Email Deborah









Tweet





submit to reddit
Email article

Print


Reprints & permissions









EXCLUSIVE





Return to video
Video settings
Please Log in to update your video settings


Video will begin in 5 seconds.

Don't play
Play now



More video
Recommended




Martial arts meets philosophy for aikido women




Shark tagging expedition off Qld coast




Scott Morrison's political bromance 




Belinda's story: a policeman's suicide




Coral trout found off Sydney





Replay video



Return to video
Video settings
Please Log in to update your video settings


New vision: Siege gunman's last moments 
Man Haron Monis can be seen standing just inside the doors of the Lindt Cafe preparing to make a move just moments before his death. 

PT0M33S

620
349

Autoplay OnOff
Video feedback
Video settings




Sydney siege gunman did not have a gun licence: NSW Police
Experts back police policy to negotiate with Monis
The survivors bound together by tragedy
Martin Place siege: more than 16 hours of terror
Sydney siege ends: how it happened
In the early hours of Tuesday morning, Sydney siege gunman Man Haron Monis was wide awake and agitated, the father of one hostage says.Joel Herat, 21, has told his family Monis was starting to herd the frightened hostages into separate groups inside the Lindt cafe, raising fears they would "not survive until the morning if they did not do something".

                                The group of hostages fleeing the cafe just before 2am.  Photo: Andrew Meares


Lawyer Bruce Herat, 52-year-old father of Joel, says his son's group of hostages decided to kick down an internal door of the Lindt cafe to make their escape.
Advertisement


It was this decisive action, his son believes, that triggered Monis unleashing the first volley of gunfire moments later.In an exclusive interview with Fairfax Media, Mr Herat says son Joel told him Monis was not falling asleep just before 2am on Tuesday  as previous reports have suggested, but was becoming increasingly agitated immediately before the first burst of gunfire rang out.

                                A hostage is carried out of Martin Place to a waiting ambulance in the early hours of Tuesday morning.  Photo: Andrew Meares


"From what Joel told me initially, towards 2am Monis started to bring groups of people together in close proximity from where they had been dispersed throughout [the cafe]", Mr Herat told Fairfax Media."And at that point in time, Joel and five others came to the conclusion that they were not going to survive until the morning if they did not do something. So I think him and Jarrod [19-year-old Jarrod Hoffman] basically came to the conclusion that they would bust down the door. And I know that Joel made sure that Harriette [Denny]  ... got behind him and he said, 'You're coming with me', and basically made sure that all that group were ready to go when Joel and Jarrod broke down the door, it was a group of six in total, I'm not sure who the others were."This was the group that was seen on TV, making a break for safety, just seconds before heavily armed tactical assault group police stormed the cafe.

                                "No opportunity to look back": Joel Herat. Photo: Supplied


"I haven't ventured to go [deeply] into the detail of it simply because I just don't want to visit that with Joel too early," Mr Herat said. "I don't know how they did it but they did kick down the [internal] door, which leads to the barristers' chambers, and then the moment they busted that door down, Joel heard shots in his proximity. And he made sure that Harriette got out and Jarrod got out .. there were shots as they were fleeing."Joel did not know what was happening to the other groups in the restaurant at that point."It had to be immediate, no opportunity to look back or anything like that, they just had to take their opportunity," his father said.Mr Herat says families of the hostages had been waiting in a special room set up by police in the old courts for several hours, getting regular briefings from police, but that for operational reasons police had decided there should be no TV in the room where they were waiting.Immediately after Joel's group made their escape, Mr Herat says, "all hell broke loose" as special police units stormed the cafe.The families could hear the commotion and "everybody in that room went to water.. everybody surged towards the street" but were initially held back."Everybody in that room just let out an awful sigh and a bit of a wail, you could see it on their faces. It sounded like instant fire but what it was was the flash grenades that were going off initially and then moments after that we knew there was bullet fire and it went on for a long, long time."Mr Herat said there was confusion for a while immediately after the assault and a wait before he knew Joel was absolutely safe. He was not reunited with his son until about 6am or 7am, and was overwhelmed to be able to embrace him again.But his heart is heavy, he says, for the two families whose loved ones - manager Tori Johnson and barrister Katrina Dawson - did not make it out.He said those families were taken aside to be given the news, but the others could hear their cries of anguish."It was the saddest thing I have ever heard," he told Fairfax Media.Earlier in the day, Monis had grown extremely agitated after the first group of hostages escaped about 4.30pm on Monday."We knew that three escaped early on, and I knew that was fabulous, but we were very much worried that some form of retribution would be taken. Luckily it wasn't but I know that when I spoke to Joel later he said that upon the first escape, [Monis] lined up five people, one of them was Joel, and pointed a gun at them and said, 'Someone must die now'."After that threat, Herat said: "I think they talked him down. It progressed to another level, in terms of them being asked to do things, put the flag up again, being positioned in certain areas where he could monitor and control them. And beyond that I don't know."The first sign that something had gone terribly wrong with his son's day came when a friend of Joel's texted his father sometime before 10am on Monday, as Mr Herat was walking to work, to ask if Joel was working at Lindt that day."I was about to reply, yes, drop in and have coffee with him.... and I asked why, and he said, "I think you had better get up there, there is a situation happening.""I just ran" Mr Herat recalls. "I ran from Chippendale to Martin Place."For the first hour he was kept at police barricades without information, and then walked around to Elizabeth Street, where he was told an interim family room was being set up in a nearby club."About two and a half hours later we were told that a special room was being set up [for the families] in the old criminal court house" Mr Herat said."We were given very neutral information first at around 2pm on Monday. Looking back it was frustrating ... but they wanted to be able to deliver information efficiently, when all the families were gathered round, rather than having to repeat it a dozen times when each of the families arrived, so I can see the logic of it."He says he has "nothing but praise for the New South Wales police".The atmosphere inside the family room was  subdued, but calm, Mr Herat says.  Numbers fluctuated through the night, some leaving as others arrived. Food and water was brought and police supplied regular updates, asking that if the hostages contacted family members  via social media they should let authorities know immediately."We all had access to smart phones which enabled us to get information from the net," Mr Herat recalls. "Joel was forced to upload the videos [of other hostages' pleas] through his Facebook and YouTube account.  I felt somewhat cold when I saw those., thinking if [the gunman] is going to that resort, then obviously he is starting to target people as emotional conduits to get what he wanted. My concern then was how far would he go."Monis was highly controlling, but also erratic in his moods, Joel reported later."He was trying to manipulate them, being nice one moment, authoritarian the next, or trying to explain that his were reasonable requests. He was trying [at times] to win the hostages over."Joel said Monis reacted sharply to noises. One that particularly set him on edge was the periodic churning of the ice machine.  "Every time that happened every hour he would turn around and say, 'someone is trying to break in - someone must die.' "'There was no obvious signs of him closing his eyes or falling asleep.". Recalling the moment when he knew his son was safe, Mr Herat describes feeling "utter relief and absolute stress just falling off you."  But then came the devastating knowledge that Tori Johnson and Katrina Dawson had not made it out alive."It was a bittersweet moment because we were absolutely shattered that their families could not be reunited as well. We were joyous for our son, but stricken with sadness for the others".As police broke the news to the bereaved families, "it was the saddest thing I've ever seen and heard in my life".Mr Herat did not tell Joel about Tori Johnson's death until they reached home on Tuesday morning. "He fell to water; he and Tori were great friends."Mr Herat says he is " enormously proud" of Joel, who is being supported by family and surrounded by friends. Joel received initial counselling after the siege was over. "At this stage I don't notice anything unusual. I'll be more worried about those quieter moments, when reflection will set in."Do you know more? Email: dsnow@fairfaxmedia.com.au

















Tweet





submit to reddit
Email article

Print


Reprints & permissions










Advertisement





Related Coverage




New vision: Siege gunman's last moments 






                Most popular
            



1




Circular Quay evacuated after package found on ...


Contains:




2




Royal Commission to publicly examine Sydney ...


Contains:




3




Sydney man Alex Pollard charged over alleged ...


Contains:




4




'Suspicious package' on ferry that shut down ...


Contains:




5




Gunman told Sydney siege survivor she had 15 ...


Contains:










LATEST VIDEO

Featured Videos More video




Martial arts meets philosophy for aikido women
Hundreds of aikido students from around the world gather in Melbourne for an intense week of training to mark 50 years of the sport in Australia, ahead of a demonstration in Fed Square on Saturday. 
PT4M7S

300
169
Thu Jan 22 22:33:10 UTC 2015





Click to play video

Newman promises 2654 health workers" 




Click to play video

Shark tagging expedition off Qld coast" 




Click to play video

Boy found after parents murdered" 













Featured advertisers









Special offers



View these special deals by Mozo.













Advertisement









Video



Australia stops without tugboats

Brisbanetimes.com.au
Entertainment and Red Carpet
Latest Sports videos
Breaking news videos




Motoring



2014 Drive Car of the Year: Full winners list

Drive.com.au
Is this the world's best parker?
Over 500 car reviews a year
Cars for sale on Drive.com.au




Find A Babysitter



Make Dating Easy with your own Trusted Babysitter!

Findababysitter.com.au
Sydney Child Care
Melbourne Child Care
Brisbane Child Care




Dating



Australia's Favourite Dating Site

Rsvp.com.au
Meet Brisbane singles
Get started for free!
Singles events for all ages




Essential Kids



33 hilarious notes from kids

Essentialkids.com.au
Lunchbox ideas & recipes
Free kids' activities and worksheets
Family recipe finder






Compare and Save

Skip to:

Best Deals
Mobile
Broadband
Home Loans
Credit Cards
Low Rate Cards
Rewards Cards
Savings Accts
Money Deals
Loans


Check out today's best deals

0% p.a. for 16 Months

Enjoy a low rate on balance transfers. Conditions apply

Find Out More


Need a Personal Loan?

No monthly fees + no penalties for early repayments

Find Out More


Boost your Savings

Compare savings accounts from leading lenders today

Compare Now


iPhone 6

We compare all carriers and deals

Compare Deals


Deals for 2015

Switching networks or staying, we compare it

Compare Deals























Readers' most viewed

Most viewed articles on Brisbane TimesTop 5 NSW articles


William Spedding says he had nothing to do with disappearance of toddler William Tyrell


Police arrest husband of woman found dead in shopping centre car park


Gunman told Sydney siege survivor she had 15 minutes to live


Female doctor suspended for having sex with patient, using Facebook to share blood test results


Caravan park searched in the hunt for missing toddler William Tyrell




Most viewed articles on WA TodayTop 5 NSW articles


Body of Renee Mitchell found after being taken while cooking family meal


Female doctor suspended for having sex with patient, using Facebook to share blood test results


Slain woman had tried to support abusive husband


Gunman told Sydney siege survivor she had 15 minutes to live


Sydney siege: 'Terribly disappointing' that hostages have sold their stories, says Jeff Kennett




Most viewed articles on The AgeTop 5 NSW articles


Gunman told Sydney siege survivor she had 15 minutes to live


William Spedding's children back him over disappearance of William Tyrell 


William Spedding says he had nothing to do with disappearance of toddler William Tyrell


Shark eats whale and snake swims through flags on the NSW coast


Police arrest husband of woman found dead in shopping centre car park




Most viewed articles on Canberra TimesTop 5 NSW articles


Woman faces court accused of throwing poo during dispute


William Spedding says he had nothing to do with disappearance of toddler William Tyrell


Gunman told Sydney siege survivor she had 15 minutes to live


'Suspicious package' on ferry that shut down Circular Quay was a training device


Boy airlifted from Merimbula after being 'dumped' at Pambula Beach




Most viewed articles on The Sydney Morning HeraldTop 5 NSW articles


William Spedding says he had nothing to do with disappearance of toddler William Tyrell


'Suspicious package' on ferry that shut down Circular Quay was a training device


Royal Commission to publicly examine Sydney private school Knox Grammar over child sexual abuse


Welder hit by 40-kilogram boulder while working on North West Rail tunnel 


Gunman told Sydney siege survivor she had 15 minutes to live









SMH Home


NSW


Politics


World


National


Environment


Business


Digital Life


Entertainment


Life & Style


Travel


Cars


Exec Style


Sport


Weather





Sydney Morning Herald


Sitemap


About Us


Contact Us


Advertise with Us


AM Today


Last 8 days


Text Version


Site Accessibility Guide





Connect


Mobile Site


SMH for iPad


Digital Edition


RSS


Facebook


Twitter


LinkedIn





Products & Services


Subscribe


Manage My Subscription


My Benefits


Good Food Guide


SMH Shop


Newsletters


Cracka Wines





Classifieds


Place an Ad


Accommodation


Cars


Dating


Jobs


Property Price Data


Real Estate


Buy and Sell


Tributes


Celebrations


Special Reports





Fairfax Media


Member Centre


Conditions of Use


Privacy Policy


News Store Archive


Photo Sales


Purchase Front Pages


Fairfax Syndication


Fairfax Events


Fairfax Careers


Press Council













Fairfax Media

Our Sites


The Sydney Morning Herald


The Age


Adzuna


Domain


Drive


RSVP


Essential Baby


InvestSMART


APM


Stayz


Weatherzone


TheVine

Our Partners


Buy & Sell


Cruises


Lawyers


Credit Cards


Business


Mechanics


Electricians


Fitness


Hair Salons


Weddings


Home Builder


Cracker


Copyright © 2015 Fairfax Media











































































