The importance of rule enforcement to local level forest management
MetadataShow full item record
Current studies of community level resource management focus on the factors that impede or help individuals to overcome their collective action problems. Dozens of factors have been identified in this literature. While important, such work is limited by the lack of theory that connects these factors with outcomes, and the near total lack of hypothesis testing beyond the case level. We argue that despite the possible differences between individuals or the characteristics of the resource they use, the regular monitoring and sanctioning of rules is a necessary condition for successful resource management. We offer a preliminary test of this hypothesis by pairing rule monitoring and sanctioning against other factors considered important in the literature, and by using a sample size of 172 user groups from the International Forestry Resources and Institutions Research Program (IFRI). We find strong support for our hypothesis that rule enforcement -- i.e. regular monitoring and sanctioning -- tends to dominate the other factors with regard to the probability that a forest is in good condition.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Scholes, M. (Pretoria, South Africa: South African Institute of Forestry, 2002)This paper discusses the use of an ecosystems approach in the management of plantations and the concept of plantations in providing goods and services. Ecological indicators are compared for the CIFOR and South African ...
Kamwenda, G.J. (Washington, D.C.: Information Service of F.A.O., 2002)Environmental degradation resulting from extensive grazing and haphazard exploitation of rangeland forestry resources is a severe problem for the agropastoralists of Shinyanga, a northeastern region of the United Republic ...
Co-evolutionary scenarios of intensification and privatization of resource use in rural communities of south-western Niger Rovere, R.; Hiernaux, P.; van Keulen, H.; Schiere, J.; Szonyi, J. (Amsterdam, Netherlands: Elsevier Science B.V., 2005)Agricultural production in the semi-arid agro-ecosystems of the Sahel centres on cereal staple crops and pastoralism with increasing crop-livestock integration. Animals mobilize soil fertility through manure production, ...