The Role of Math Courses in Engineering Education: Examining How Math Courses Shape First-Year Student Transition, Curriculum Complexity, and Time-to-Degree

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

TR Number

Date

2026-05-26

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Virginia Tech

Abstract

Mathematics is foundational to engineering, yet it often functions as a gatekeeper. Most engineering programs follow a rigid, hierarchical curriculum that assumes students begin in Calculus 1 during their first semester to remain on track. However, many students enter engineering and do not place into Calculus 1, instead beginning in Pre-Calculus. Due to long prerequisite chains, these students frequently fall behind their peers and must complete additional coursework to progress through the curriculum. Although mathematics is important to engineering, the way the curriculum is structured can unintentionally exclude interested and motivated students who do not place directly into Calculus 1, which unnecessarily limits who can study engineering. This concern is particularly concerning in the current context, as mathematics achievement and standardized test scores among U.S. students declined following the COVID-19 pandemic and have not yet recovered to pre-pandemic levels, with disparities across school characteristics. These conditions underscore the need to more closely examine the role of mathematics in shaping pathways into and through engineering education. My multi-study dissertation provides a holistic overview of the role of math courses in engineering across three manuscripts. In the first study, I conducted semi-structured interviews during the 2022-2023 school year with 15 first-year engineering students enrolled in Calculus 1 in their second semester. I thus considered "off track" from the prescribed engineering math sequence. Most of the participants were in high school during the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic, learning Algebra and Pre-Calculus. Using Schlossberg's transition theory, I illuminate students' experiences transitioning to remote learning during the pandemic and how it impacted their math readiness, as well as their transition to the university and into engineering. Students had varied experiences transitioning to remote learning, with complicated hybrid learning systems that affected their math readiness. Students' transition to university was further affected by their math readiness status, but the impact of being considered "off track" in math did not have equal impacts across students. In the second study, I quantify and compare curriculum complexity and math cruciality (the proportion of a curriculum's complexity attributable to required math courses) across engineering disciplines and institutions, while also examining the relationship between complexity and institutional and program characteristics. The findings showed that Mechanical Engineering had the highest complexity score, compared to Civil and Electrical Engineering. However, despite differences in curriculum complexity across disciplines, the required math courses consistently accounted for approximately 30% of the curriculum's complexity. I also found differences in the required math courses across disciplines: beyond the core calculus sequence, there is significant variation. I also used regression and cluster analyses to examine how program and institutional characteristics shape complexity trends; these analyses revealed that less selective institutions often exhibit higher curriculum complexity scores. In the third study, I use a large institutional dataset to examine how students' math placement and the complexity of their major can relate to their time-to-degree. I used the Multiple Institution Database for Investigating Engineering Longitudinal Development (MIDFIELD) alongside a MIDFIELD curriculum complexity dataset to examine the relationship between math placement, curriculum complexity, and time-to-degree for engineering students. I used a Hierarchical Linear Model to identify factors predicting time-to-degree and a two-way ANOVA to examine how an engineering student's math placement affects the curriculum complexity of the major they chose. The model showed that an engineering student's first math course was the most significant predictor of time-to-degree, and students who start in different math courses pursue majors with differing curriculum complexity scores. Across these manuscripts, I provide a holistic overview of the role of math courses in the engineering curriculum. By focusing on the role of math courses, I hope to illuminate how mathematics often acts as a structural barrier in engineering education, but can also be used as a lever for change.

Description

Keywords

engineering education, mathematics, curriculum, curriculum complexity

Citation