Evaluating the Relationship Between Equine Pain and Behavior
Files
TR Number
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
Pain is physical and emotional discomfort caused by a variety of diseases and injuries. While the exact prevalence of pain in horses is unknown, it is likely a common ailment. Additionally, previous research has determined that owners frequently do not recognize pain in horses. This dissertation examined both assessment of pain and a disease that might cause pain. First, I compared responses to two commonly used pain assessment methods: manual palpation and pressure algometry, and used a cluster method to group the responses. Responses were behaviors such as a muscle twitch, tail swish or step. Manual palpation uses a person's hands to touch various areas on a horse to see if the horse responds with a behavior that suggests pain. Pressure algometry uses a digital device that gives a number called the mechanical nociceptive threshold, which is the amount of pressure that was applied when the horse responds with a behavior. There were 46 manual palpation points and 15 pressure algometer points. These points were divided into nine anatomical regions: head, neck, withers, shoulder, front leg, girth, back, hip, and back leg. From the first study, I determined that behavior responses by anatomical region were similar for both manual palpation and pressure algometry testing and therefore only one of these tests was needed if only examining behavior responses. A cluster analysis grouped both the pressure algometer behavior responses and mechanical nociceptive threshold into clusters that were based on anatomical regions. However, a cluster analysis did not create anatomical groups for the manual palpation test. For the second study, I used three pain assessment methods: Equinosis Lameness Locator, manual palpation test, and pressure algometer test to evaluate horses with and without outer surface protein F antibodies to Borrelia burgdorferi. The Equinosis Lameness Locator is a three-sensor system that provides three numerical outputs for any movement asymmetries in millimeters. For this study, I found that horses with B. burgdorferi antibodies had decreased head movement responses on the caudal neck and a higher muscle twitch response count during the pressure algometer exam. However, these horses also had a decreased Equinosis Diff Max Pelvis number meaning that horses with antibodies were moving more symmetrically than horses without antibodies. Additionally, while not related to the tests used to evaluate pain, the overall seroprevalence of horses has increased in the southwest Virginia area. For the third study, I used a sound sensitivity test to determine if horses in varying lameness groups responded differently to repeated sounds as previous research in dogs has found that dogs with orthopedic pain may develop sound sensitivities. In this study, 70% of the horses had decreased behavior reactions when comparing the day one behavior after the sound to the day five behavior after the sound. This means that most horses that are exposed to repeated sounds will habituate to the sound. However, five horses (14%) had increasing behavior between day one and day five. These five horses were in the moderate and high lameness group and there were no horses in the low lameness group that had an increased behavior reaction between day one and day five. Overall, results from these studies help improve our understanding of pain assessments and behaviors; and also, how to apply these assessments to a disease.