Processing Matters: Neural and Metabolic Responses to Ultraprocessed Foods
Files
TR Number
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
The modern food environment has undergone a rapid shift toward greater degrees of food processing. Under the Nova classification system, ultraprocessed foods (UPFs) are defined as industrially formulated products that undergo multiple physical and chemical transformations and typically contain additives and ingredients not commonly used in household cooking. UPF consumption has been linked to a range of adverse health outcomes, yet UPFs account for the majority of calories consumed in the United States. Although common attributes of UPFs that promote consumption, such as high energy density and macronutrient composition, have been extensively studied, the direct effects of ultraprocessing itself remain comparatively underexamined. To address this gap in knowledge in Chapter 1 we introduce a novel food picture set comprising 28 commonly consumed foods in the United States that differ on degree of processing while still being carefully matched across 26 visual, nutritional, and perceptual properties to enable the controlled investigation of UPF. Additionally, we derived the Nova classifications for these foods with a strong inter-rater reliability from both non-nutrition- credentialed individuals and credentialed nutrition professionals, directly addressing a noted critique of the Nova system. Next, in Chapter 2, we demonstrated that UPF and non-UPF meals matched across multiple nutritional factors elicit distinct post-ingestive metabolic profiles, characterized by amplified insulinemic and energetic responses and attenuated carbohydrate oxidation following UPF consumption. These processing-related metabolic differences were associated with differential neural responses within reward circuitry to food cues varying in degree of processing, as assessed using the picture set developed in Chapter 1. Finally, we showed that degree of processing does not alter behavioral indices of value but does alter neural representation, specifically throughout the striatum and occipitotemporal gyrus. Collectively, this work provides support for the concept that food processing influences physiology and brain function through mechanisms extending beyond calories and macronutrient composition alone, while identifying altered nutritional availability from altered physical structure as a plausible contributor to both their consumption and effects on metabolic health.