Understanding and Predicting the Presence and Efficacy of the Work Children Show When Solving Math Word Problems

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

TR Number

Date

2026-06-12

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Virginia Tech

Abstract

Solving math word problems is a complex undertaking that requires the integration of conceptual and procedural mathematics knowledge, executive functioning skills, and reading skills. This complexity means that word problems are challenging for many children and that different children may need different types of support from their teachers. Showing work when solving word problems is an important tool for helping teachers understand how to support children in the classroom, especially those who are struggling. It may also support children in arriving at the correct answer. However, little is known about the nature of the work that children show spontaneously, child characteristics that predict the likelihood of showing work, or how showing work relates to problem-solving performance. To address this gap in the literature, this study examined relations among the work that fourth grade children show, metacognition and math motivation as child characteristics related to showing work, and word problem-solving accuracy. Additionally, exploratory interviews were conducted with children to better understand how children perceive their own thought processes surrounding the decision to show or not show work. In this behavioral study, 92 children participated in a one-on-one session in which they completed a measure of their math motivation (math self-efficacy and math value), solved nine word problems (later coded for the presence or absence of shown work), completed post-diction ratings of their performance on those word problems, participated in an interview regarding their problem-solving process for three of those word problems, and completed prediction ratings of their performance on word problems that were isomorphic to those they actually solved. Children also completed measures of working memory, reading fluency, and math fluency. Findings indicate that children make and act on metacognitive judgments about their own abilities when deciding whether to show or not show work during word problem-solving tasks. Children were more likely to show work for more difficult problems; however, they were less likely to show work for problems that they were confident they would answer correctly. There was no moderating effect of working memory on the relation between this metacognitive assessment and the frequency of showing work throughout the problem set. Showing work was significantly associated with arriving at the correct answer for difficult problems, but not for easy problems. Children's sense of math self-efficacy was only predictive of showing work on difficult problems; it was not predictive of showing work on problems generally. Children's math value was not predictive of showing work overall or at any difficulty level. In interviews discussing problem-solving processes, children referenced their own metacognitive or metastrategic thought processes, conceptual knowledge, procedural approaches, the researcher, and academic expectations as relevant to their decision to show or not show work. These explanations were present with similar frequency between boys and girls; however, analyses suggest that there may be gender differences in how these explanations relate to other child-level characteristics, such as math value. This study points to future research directions while also offering practical implications for classroom educators.

Description

Keywords

Metacognition, Math Motivation, Showing Work, Word Problem Solving, Middle Childhood

Citation