A Just Transition?: Syndemic Health Impacts of Extractivism
Files
TR Number
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
Extractivism is a political-economic model often characterized by large-scale resource extraction, driven by an ideology that prioritizes capital accumulation over the well-being of people and places. Mining, though distinct from extractivism as a concept, is a central and widely recognized example of extractivism in practice and is projected to intensify as demand for different types of raw materials, including rare earth minerals, grows, particularly in the context of the global energy transition. The negative human, environmental, political, social, and economic impacts of many forms of mining are becoming increasingly well-documented, with notable evidence of these effects in regions such as Central Appalachia (USA), Olopa (Guatemala), and beyond. This dissertation employs a community-based participatory research (CBPR) approach, utilizing semi-structured interviews and participatory GIS/mapping to examine local perceptions and patterns of risk, health, and barriers to action. Chapter 1 provides an overview of relevant literature and introduces key concepts to be explored in subsequent chapters. Chapter 2 analyzes qualitative data on the community and social health impacts of extractivism in Central Appalachia, while Chapter 3 focuses on the environmental and human health consequences in the same region. Chapter 4 introduces the concept of strategic quiescence, theorizing it as a rational response to limited agency in coal-impacted communities, challenging stereotypes of non-action in the Appalachian region. Chapter 5 expands the analysis with a cross-case comparison, drawing from both the Central Appalachian study and a prior study in Guatemala to explore the similarities and differences in extractivism's impacts across distinct contexts. The findings underscore the importance of community-driven research and participatory methodologies in understanding the multifaceted impacts of extractivism and environmental injustice. The results of this work raise questions about the sustainability of energy transitions that prioritize decarbonization while simultaneously creating new sacrifice zones, and offers novel insights into the health effects of extractivism through a syndemic framework, highlighting the interrelated drivers of these health crises and identifying potential intervention points. As the global push for new energy technologies grows, this dissertation emphasizes the need for mitigation and proactive measures to prevent the replication of these destructive practices at future sites of extraction.