Understanding angler heterogeneity in recreational fisheries science and management in the Great Lakes
Files
TR Number
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
Recreational fisheries research and management treat anglers as a relatively homogeneous population that primarily participates for sports or fun. This approach can obscure differences in why people fish, how they use fisheries resources, what they catch, and how they evaluate management institutions. In this dissertation, I examined angler heterogeneity and its implications for fisheries management, monitoring, and governance among shore-based fishers in urban communities in the lower Great Lakes.
In the first study (i.e. Chapter 2), I used survey data from 443 shore anglers across 10 cities around Lakes Erie and Ontario to identify the principal dimensions of angler diversity. Using latent class analysis, I identified three distinct angler groups along a food provisioning–leisure/sport continuum: provisioning/food-oriented anglers, cultural/community-oriented anglers, and leisure/sport-oriented anglers. These findings demonstrate that recreational and non-recreational values coexist within urban shore fisheries, and that food provisioning and cultural practices are important components of angler diversity.
Building on these angler groups, I examined whether this orientation-based angler heterogeneity was associated with differences in catch and species use in Chapter 3. Using directed acyclic graph-informed models, hierarchical catch models, and hierarchical Bernoulli models, I found that provisioning/food-oriented anglers had the highest model-standardized expected catch (535 lb per angler), approximately 1.8 times that of leisure/sport-oriented anglers (302 lb per angler). The expected catch for cultural/community-oriented anglers was intermediate (389 lb per angler). The groups also diverged in target species as provisioning/food-oriented anglers were most associated with carp and catfish/bullhead, cultural/community anglers with walleye and perch, and leisure/sport anglers with bass. Since current monitoring relies on aggregate catch metrics and has no specific estimates for provisioning/food-oriented and cultural/community-oriented angler groups, my findings suggest that current estimates can conceal systematic differences in catch intensity and fishery use among anglers. Therefore, current estimates may underestimate fishing intensity exerted by high-catch subgroups and overlook species-specific impacts.
In Chapter 4, I investigated how multidimensional trust influences fishers' willingness to support fisheries authorities. Using confirmatory factor analysis and structural equation modeling with survey data from 385 recreational fishers in Southern Ontario, I found that affinitive, rational, and procedural trust were highly intercorrelated and best represented as a higher-order actionable trust construct. Actionable trust exerted a strong positive effect on support intention, whereas dispositional trust operated only indirectly. A hybrid deductive–inductive thematic analysis of qualitative responses further revealed that fishers' trust-building expectations span multiple trust dimensions simultaneously.
My dissertation demonstrates that recreational fisheries in the Great Lakes are socially heterogeneous systems in which distinct orientation-based angler groups differ in their potential ecological footprints. Findings indicate that management and monitoring frameworks must account for orientation-specific patterns across anglers, and that fisheries management agencies can strengthen voluntary cooperation by deliberately cultivating multidimensional trust. These insights contribute to a more nuanced understanding of recreational fisheries in the lower Great Lakes.