From Policy to Practice: A Multi-Scale Analysis of Vision Zero Implementation

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

TR Number

Date

2026-10-20

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Virginia Tech

Abstract

Vision Zero is a transportation safety approach that originated in Sweden in 1997. It aims to eliminate all traffic related fatalities or serious injuries and is based on the Safe System Approach. The Safe System Approach is a novel transportation safety initiative that shifts the responsibility of a car crash from the driver to the design of the system. Hence, responsibility is shared amongst all stakeholders and not solely dependent on human error. Since it was implemented in Sweden, Vision Zero has spread globally and shown promising success. However, with this global spread, implementation has varied throughout, making it difficult to understand which components of Vision Zero contribute the most to safety outcomes. This dissertation examines Vision Zero through three studies to understand the framework, perceptions, and implementation intensity of Vision Zero initiatives. The first study focuses on four cases to create a comprehensive framework to characterize Vision Zero implementation. The second study seeks practitioner and researcher input to understand how Vision Zero is perceived. The last study applied the framework developed in the first study to Swedish counties, to analyze if implementation intensity affected fatality outcomes from 2019 to 2024. The findings of these studies were synthesized to paint a holistic picture of Vision Zero implementation. Findings suggest that Vision Zero is more complex than policy adoption alone and is dependent on the strategies and intensity. Implementation intensity was calculated through the index developed in the first study, and a negative binomial regression model was run to assess the index's correlation to fatality rates. The model found that higher implementation intensity was associated with a lower fatality incidence rate. These results were then compared to the survey results to identify if the model was cohesive with what practitioners and researchers encountered. Their perceptions, however, did not always align with the findings from the model, and some implementation challenges they experienced could not be wholly captured in the implementation intensity index or framework. Overall, the findings strengthen the idea that Vision Zero is a collection of different strategies that all work toward eliminating traffic fatalities and serious injuries. Evaluating how these strategies are implemented may be able to provide a more meaningful understanding of Vision Zero effectiveness.

Description

Keywords

Transportation, Safety, Vision Zero, Transportation Policy, Implementation Framework, Road Safety, Safe System Approach

Citation