On the Stage of Change: A Dramaturgical Approach to Violence, Social Protests, and Policing Styles in the U.S.
Ratliff, Thomas N.
MetadataShow full item record
Social movement scholars have contended that considerable research on protest policing has been done, but research testing multiple theories in recent decades is lacking. To resolve this gap in the literature, this study integrates major paradigms in repression research and theories of policing styles around a dramaturgical approach to collective action, identifying factors influencing violence at social protests in the United States from 2006-2009. Conceiving of social protest as a form of political and symbolic action, I maintain that social actors and the qualities of their actions and immediate environment importantly influence a protest eventâ s characteristics and outcomes. Specifically, I code for three violent outcomesâ arrests, police violence, and any violenceâ and one measure of threatâ police presence. I identify four components of the protest event which influence these outcomesâ actors (e.g., authorities, protesters, and counterprotesters), enemies (e.g., the target of protestersâ claims), the stage (e.g., qualities of place and space where a protest occurs), and protest performance (e.g., protest size and specific tactics employed by actors). Thus, this research focuses on how qualities of police, protester, and counterprotester performances intersect to influence violence at protest events. Data for this project were collected from multiple sources from 2006-2009. Information on protest events was collected by content coding of newspaper articles in the Los Angeles Times and New York Times. Information on community policing styles was derived from lists of funding for agencies participating in the U.S. Department of Justiceâ s Community Oriented Policing Services (COPS) program. In some instances the results of this study show that certain characteristics leading to police presence and violence at social protests in the U.S. persist from research conducted on earlier decadesâ presence of African Americans or counterprotesters, protester use of â more confrontationalâ tactics and/or multiple tactics, and the damaging of property by protesters or counterprotesters. However, my findings also contradict previous studies, because I find that: (1) larger protests are less likely to be policed or result in violence; (2) social and cultural targets are more likely predictors of policing and violence rather than government or economic ones; and, (3) specific social movement families and tactical types influence protest event outcomes differently. I also found that community policing styles had no effect on protest event policing. These findings are important because they show how a protest eventâ s symbolic nature influences policing and violent outcomes.
- Doctoral Dissertations 
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Geography of development: Development, civil society and inequality - social capital is (almost) dead? Radcliffe, S.A.This article examines social capital controversies in the development field. Social capital's approach to social interaction has not analyzed social differences, such as gender and ethnicity. Some questions are being asked ...
Conteras, D.; Kruger, D.; Ochoa, M.; Zapata, D.The authors used empirical analysis to understand the role that networks play in income-generating activities of Bolivian women. Women are an important contributor of household income, and between 20 to 50 percent are the ...
Capital, community and collective action: Social foundations of sustainability in an Andean buffer zone (Ecuador) Flora, J.Development approaches have traditionally emphasized material resources, ignoring the less tangible forms of capital. But sustainable development, especially in relation to land use and production systems, calls for an ...