Effects of forest disturbance on shredder production in headwater streams

Effects of forest disturbance on leaf shredding aquatic insects were investigated by comparing leaf biomass and shredder production in disturbed versus reference forest streams. Benthic samples were collected monthly in 3 streams in a mature hardwood reference forest and 3 streams in an 11-year-old clearcut. Reference forest streams had significantly greater total leaf biomass and significantly more slow-processing leaf material than disturbed forest streams. Disturbed forest streams had significantly greater fast-processing leaf biomass than did reference streams.

The leaf shredding insects Tipula abdominalis, Pycnopsyche sp., and Tallaperla maria comprised over 90% of the shredder biomass in all streams. Total shredder production was Significantly greater (p<0.05) in disturbed versus reference streams. Production of Pycnopsyche and T. maria was significantly greater (p <0.10) in disturbed versus reference streams, but T. abdominalis production was not significantly different (po =0.28). Greater T. maria production was attributed mostly to better survivorship in disturbed versus reference streams. Greater total shredder production in disturbed streams was attributed mostly to greater production by Pycnopsyche, which was due mostly to better survivorship and growth of early instar larvae in disturbed streams.

T. maria and T. abdominalis were studied under laboratory conditions to determine whether feeding on various types of leaf material would affect growth. Shredder growth rates were affected more by length of instream conditioning of leaves than leaf species or leaf exposure site. Each shredder species had different patterns of growth and survivorship relative to leaf species and conditioning. There was no difference in shredder growth patterns between early versus late successional leaf species. Pycnopsyche growth was not studied, but Pycnopsyche may be more capable than the other shredders of exploiting fast-processing, early successional leaf species.

Pycnopsyche production was greatest in streams having the greatest quantities of early successional leaf biomass. Pycnopsyche biomass correlated significantly with fast-processing leaf biomass typical of the early successional forest, whereas other shredders did not.

Shredder production was significantly greater in disturbed versus reference forest streams, even though total leaf biomass was significantly greater in reference streams. Providing that forest clearcutting is accomplished with minimal physical disturbance to streams, shredder populations may exhibit greater production in streams 11-years after forest clearcutting than in reference forest streams.