Do Roots Bind Soil? Comparing the Physical and Biological Role of Plant Roots in Streambank Fluvial Erosion

This study is the first to consider how the combination of root physical effects, microbial production of EPS, and root effects on the hydrodynamic boundary layer could influence streambank soil erodibility. Specifically, the goal of this research was to quantify the physical and biological effects of roots on streambank fluvial erosion. A series of laboratory-scale erosion tests were conducted using a mini jet erosion testing device and a recirculating flume channel to address this goal. Several soil and vegetation factors that influence fluvial entrainment, like extracellular polymeric substances (EPS), soil aggregate stability and root length density, were measured following erosion testing. For flume experiments, three streambank boundary conditions were constructed to simulate unvegetated streambanks, as well as streambanks with herbaceous and woody roots. Soil treatments were also created to represent unamended and organic matter (OM) amended soil either without roots (bare soil), with synthetic roots, or with living roots (Panicum virgatum).

Median soil erosion rates along the simulated rooted boundaries were two to ten times higher compared to the unvegetated boundary due to protruding root impacts on the boundary layer. In flume experiments, median erosion rates were 30% to 72% lower for unamended soils containing compacted synthetic root fibers as compared to bare soil samples. Adding both OM and fibers to the soil had a greater effect; the median erosion rate reductions of live rooted treatments (95% to 100%) and synthetic rooted + OM treatments (86% to 100%) were similar and statistically lower than bare soil controls. Stimulated microbial production of EPS proteins were significantly correlated with increased erosion resistance in OM-amended treatments while OM treatments had significantly lower EPS carbohydrates compared to unamended treatments. In summary, while sparsely spaced roots exposed on streambanks may increase soil erosion rates due to impacts on the hydrodynamic boundary layer, overall results highlight how the synergistic relationship between root fibers and soil microbes can significantly reduce streambank soil erodibility due to fiber reinforcement and EPS production.