Exposure heterogeneity, host immunity and virulence evolution in a wild bird-bacterium system

Immunological heterogeneity is the norm in most free-living vertebrate populations, creating a diverse and challenging landscape for pathogens to replicate and transmit. This dissertation work sought to determine sources of immunological heterogeneity, as well as the consequences of this heterogeneity on pathogen fitness and evolution. A major source of heterogeneity in free-living host populations is the degree of exposure to a pathogen, as well as a host's history of exposure to a pathogen, which can create variation in standing immunity. We sought to determine the role of exposure heterogeneity on host susceptibility and immunity to secondary infection, and the influence of this heterogeneity on pathogen fitness and virulence evolution in a wild bird-bacterium system. We first determined that exposure level has a significant effect on host susceptibility to infection, severity of disease and infection, as well as immunity produced to secondary infection. Subsequently, we tested whether exposure history, and the immunity formed from this previous exposure, altered the within-host fitness advantage to virulent pathogens. We determined that previous low-level repeat exposure, which wild hosts likely encounter while foraging, produces a within-host environment which greatly favors more virulent pathogens. While within-host processes are vital for understanding and interpreting the evolutionary pressures on a pathogen, the ultimate metric of pathogen fitness is transmission. We therefore tested whether exposure history altered the transmission potential of a host and whether prior host exposure selected for more virulent pathogens. The transmission potential of a host significantly decreased with previous exposure, and high levels of previous exposure selected for more virulent pathogens. While we anticipated selection to be strongest at low-levels of exposure based on our previous results, we found here that high doses of prior exposure resulted in the strongest transmission advantage to virulence. This study also provided insight into the nuanced nature of transmission, which our results indicate is determined both by the degree of within-host pathogen replication as well as host disease severity. Together, our findings underscore the importance of exposure level and exposure history in natural populations in determining susceptibility, immunity and pathogen virulence evolution.