To Mix or Not to Mix: Performance and Management of Diverse Cover Crop Mixtures

Cover crops (CC) are planted in between cash crops to improve soil quality and to supply nitrogen (N) to cash crops through biological N fixation or soil N scavenging. Most producers use single species CC, in part because potential benefits of using mixtures of three or more CC species are poorly understood. A three-year study was initiated at Painter, Virginia to observe effects of CC mixtures on a no-till (NT) corn (Zea mays), wheat (Triticum aestivum L.), and soybean (Glycine max) rotation to measure CC performance, N cycling, cash crop yield, and soil quality in a sandy, low organic matter soil. Twelve treatments were created with conventional tillage (CT), NT, no CC control, and monoculture or CC mixtures of 3 to 9 species. Corn was grown in year 3 in all 12 treatments and four N rates were applied (0, 56, 112 and 156 kg N ha-1). Cover crop biomass, N accumulation, CC C:N ratio, and corn and soybean yield were measured annually. Soil bulk density, compaction, infiltration rate, pH, electrical conductivity, soil respiration, earthworm counts, soil microbial respiration, and soil microbial biomass carbon (C) after three years of CC. Cover crop biomass production varied significantly each year (5633 kg ha-1 in year 1, 755 kg ha-1 in year 2, 5370 kg ha-1 in year 3) due to climate and agronomic parameters, but a CC mixture always produced the highest biomass at termination. Nitrogen accumulation was strongly correlated with biomass production (R2= 0.94) and followed the same trend due to all CC having C:N < 30:1. Corn and soybean yields in years 1 and 2 were not significantly different, but corn yield was significantly affected by treatment and N fertilizer rate in year 3. After 3 years, soil respiration, earthworm populations and soil microbial biomass C increased in CC compared to CT without CC. However, infiltration rate, bulk density, microbial respiration, pH did not improve or declined compared to CT. In conclusion, adding CC mixtures to crop rotations shows promise for producing high CC biomass, accumulating N, and increasing crop yields, while improving some soil quality parameters on sandy low organic matter soils.