Effectiveness of Vehicle External Communication Toward Improving Vulnerable Road User Safe Behaviors: Considerations for Legacy Vehicles to Automated Vehicles of the Future

TR Number
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Virginia Tech

Automated vehicles (AVs) will be integrated into our society at some point in the future, but when is still up for debate. An extensive amount of research is being completed to understand the communication methods between AVs and other road users sharing the environment to prepare for this future. Currently, researchers are working to understand how different forms of external communication on the AVs will impact vulnerable road user (VRU) interaction. However, within the last 10 years, VRU casualty rates have continued to rise for all classifications of VRUs. Unfortunately, there is no suggestion that pedestrian fatality rates will ever decrease without some intervention. This dissertation aims at understanding the impacts of eHMI across real-world, complex scenarios with AVs and how researchers can apply those future findings to improve VRUs' judgments to today. A series of studies evaluated the necessity and impact of eHMI on AV–VRU interaction, assessed how the visual components of eHMI influenced VRU crossing decisions, and how variations in a real-world environment (multiple vehicles and scenario complexity) impact crossing decision behavior. Two studies examined how eHMI will impact future interactions between AVs and VRUs. Specifically, to understand how to advance the design of these future devices to avoid unintended consequences that may result. Results from these studies found that the presence and condition of eHMI did not influence participants' willingness to cross. Participants primarily relied on the speed and distance of the vehicle to make their crossing decision. It was difficult for participants to focus on the eHMI when multiple vehicles competed for their attention. Participants typically prioritized their focus on the vehicle that was nearest and most detrimental to their crossing path. Additionally, the type of scenario caused participants to make more cautious crossing decisions. However, it did not influence their willingness to cross. The last study applied the learnings from the first two studies to a foundational perception study for current legacy vehicles. These results showed a significant increase in judgment accuracies with a display. Through analysis across overall conclusions from the 3 studies, five critical findings were identified when addressing eHMI and 3 design recommendations, which are discussed in the penultimate section of this work. The results of this dissertation indicate that eHMI improved VRUs' accuracy of perception of change in vehicle speed. eHMI did not significantly impact VRUs crossing decisions. However, the complexity of the traffic scenarios affected the level of caution participants exhibited in their crossing behavior.

automated vehicles, external communication, pedestrian safety, vulnerable road users, external human machine interfaces, eHMI, crossing decisions, pedestrians, road crossing, safety, vehicle speed estimation, street crossing, autonomous vehicles