Measuring and modeling the effects of fatigue on performance: Specific application to the nursing profession

TR Number
Date
2009-07-21
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Virginia Tech
Abstract

High rates of medical errors are well documented within the healthcare industry. Nurses, in particular, play a critical role in the quality and safety of healthcare services. Fatigue is a factor that has been linked to stress, safety, and performance decrements in numerous work environments. Within healthcare, however, a comprehensive definition of fatigue encompassing multiple dimensions has not been considered, but is warranted since nurses perform tasks consisting of diverse physical and mental activities. As such, "total fatigue" was examined, as were interactions between its underlying dimensions and the effects of these dimensions on performance, in the context of actual and simulated nursing work.

In a survey study (Chapter 2), registered nurses reported relatively high levels of mental, physical, and total fatigue, and higher levels of fatigue were associated with perceived decreases in performance. Work environment variables, such as work schedule or shift length, were also related to differences in reported fatigue levels.

An experimental study investigated causal effects of mental and physical fatigue on mental and physical performance (Chapter 3). Mental fatigue affected a measure of mental performance, and physical fatigue had a negative effect on measures of physical and mental performance. A multidimensional view of fatigue that considers direct and crossover effects between mental and physical dimensions of fatigue and performance is relevant when quantifying effects of fatigue on performance.

A model of the relationships between fatigue dimensions and performance in nursing was developed using structural equation modeling techniques (Chapter 4). The model supported the existence of a total fatigue construct that is directly affected by mental and physical fatigue levels. The final model also provides quantitative path coefficients defining the strength of relationships between mental and physical dimensions of fatigue, total fatigue, and mental and physical performance.

The current research provides an increased understanding of fatigue levels in registered nurses across work environments, as well as the underlying causal mechanisms between dimensions of fatigue and performance decrements. The findings and the final model can aid in designing interventions to reduce or eliminate the contributions of fatigue to the occurrence of medical errors.

Description
Keywords
Fatigue, medical errors, nursing, structural equation modeling, Performance
Citation