The Impact of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction, Sex, and Sport-specific, Game-like Factors on Limb Stiffness and Limb Stiffness Asymmetry during Landing

Non-contact injuries can occur when athletes use poor or inconsistent mechanics during typical sport-related movements like landing from a jump. Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries are especially devastating, and certain populations like female athletes and athletes with a previous ACL reconstruction (ACLR) are at greater risk of suffering an ACL injury, with altered biomechanical strategies being one proposed reason. Asymmetric landings where one limb experiences greater landing force can decrease joint stability and place the overloaded limb at greater risk for ACL injury. Additionally, a stiff landing, characterized by increased ground reaction force (GRF), extended joints at initial ground contact, and decreased joint flexion throughout the landing, has been proposed to increase ACL injury risk. While load distribution between limbs is a common landing assessment to determine injury risk, it is unclear what role limb stiffness plays in the likelihood of experiencing an ACL injury. Limb stiffness is simply the deformation of the limb in response to the downward force applied to the lower limb during ground contact, which can be approximated using GRF. Limb stiffness has been commonly used to assess performance in running, hopping, and jumping, however, its relationship with injury risk during landings is relatively unexplored. Past research has revealed that the ACL experiences peak strain prior to initial ground contact when the knee is at or near full extension. Additionally, expert video analyses have determined that ACL injuries most likely occur within 50 milliseconds of ground contact. It is possible that limb stiffness and limb stiffness asymmetry can be used during the early impact phase of landings to reveal ACLR- and sex-specific landing mechanics differences when the ACL appears to be most vulnerable. Moreover, game-like, sport-specific landing tasks with a greater horizontal component that load the ACL and those that divert attention away from landing strategies may uncover differences that do not appear in standard, controlled laboratory tasks. The overall goal of this project was to use limb stiffness, limb stiffness asymmetry, and related measures to analyze the early landing phase mechanics of groups at greater risk for ACL injury during game-like, sport-specific landings. First, in an ACLR cohort, greater knee power and knee work asymmetries were found when compared to healthy recreational athletes, supporting previous literature that found that athletes with an ACLR land unevenly by offloading their surgical limb. However, limb stiffness asymmetry was not different between groups, implying that the groups may have modulated limb stiffness differently between limbs. Second, minimal sex-by-task interactions were determined for landings that varied by horizontal approach prior to initial ground contact. Significant differences were found for most measures across tasks overall, however, male and female athletes displayed similar landing mechanics, indicating that expected sex-specific differences may not exist during the immediate landing phase when ACL injuries are thought to occur. Last a landing task that mimicked a ball in mid-air and diverted attention away from landing mechanics produced a sex-by-task interaction for peak impact force but no other measure. When comparing each sex-task pairing, a trend for greater peak impact force by female athletes during the distracted landing (p=0.098) was found which may indicate that future tasks with additional external focuses or another game-like component will reveal anticipated sex-specific differences. Increased time between limbs for initial ground contact for female athletes also revealed that a time-synchronized assessment of between-limb coordination may be beneficial for future research.