Bayesian Model Selection for Spatial Data and Cost-constrained Applications

Bayesian model selection is a useful tool for identifying an appropriate model class, dependence structure, and valuable predictors for a wide variety of applications. In this work we consider objective Bayesian model selection where no subjective information is available to inform priors on model parameters a priori, specifically in the case of hierarchical models for spatial data, which can have complex dependence structures. We develop an approach using trained priors via fractional Bayes factors where standard Bayesian model selection methods fail to produce valid probabilities under improper reference priors. This enables researchers to concurrently determine whether spatial dependence between observations is apparent and identify important predictors for modeling the response. In addition to model selection with objective priors on model parameters, we also consider the case where the priors on the model space are used to penalize individual predictors a priori based on their costs. We propose a flexible approach that introduces a tuning parameter to cost-penalizing model priors that allows researchers to control the level of cost penalization to meet budget constraints and accommodate increasing sample sizes.