Many ecosystems are losing biodiversity, raising concern for the services they provide. However, the extent of loss is uncertain, especially for insects that use freshwater during their life. Further study is needed to assess freshwater insect abundances and diversity. In Central Appalachian streams, macroinvertebrate diversity declines in response to mining-induced salinization and resulting changes to ecosystem processes remain largely unknown, such as how the availability and movement of macroinvertebrate biomass is altered in stream food webs. However, taxa observed are dependent upon sampling effort that could bias diversity-process interpretation. Taxon sampling curves can be used to estimate sampling effort that maximizes the probability of complete community characterization. We sampled six streams in the Central Appalachian region for benthic macroinvertebrates and explored the number of samples needed to capture taxonomic richness in salinized streams. Sampling effort did not differ between reference and salinized streams, though more uneven distributions of macroinvertebrates in salinized streams seemed to necessitate greater sampling effort relative to reference streams. We also used taxon and trait-based sampling curves to expand our understanding of biodiversity and functional responses to environmental change. Because macroinvertebrate biomass and emergence can assess the movement and changes in organic material and energy in response to a salinization gradient, we added them as additional metrics. Macroinvertebrates may have varied responses to a stressor dependent upon life stage, suggesting that assessments relying only on immatures may not fully characterize the effects of salinization. We sampled benthic macroinvertebrate biomass and emergent insect biomass from six streams in the Central Appalachian region to be representative of a salinization gradient. We predicted benthic biomass would either decrease, be maintained by greater density and biomass of salt-tolerant taxa, or increase from a salt subsidy effect, while emergent biomass would decrease disproportionately relative to benthic biomass due to late instar and pupae succumbing to stress. Our results suggest that total benthic macroinvertebrate biomass is maintained along a salinization gradient despite the loss of salt-sensitive mayflies due to compensation by salt-tolerant taxa that experience a subsidizing effect. Emergent biomass was variable among streams with peak emergence occurring in spring, with no apparent negative response to increasing conductivity. The present study can help to further develop metrics of stream ecosystem processes in response to a disturbance gradient.