Participation of Landowners in Bird-Friendly Maple: Consideration for Third-party Certification and Birding Trail Development

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

TR Number

Date

2026-05-14

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Virginia Tech

Abstract

Private land constitutes more than two-thirds of the land in the United States and has immense conservation potential to protect wildlife habitats. Conservation organizations that emphasize approaches addressing landowners' educational, economic, and social needs may increase participation in private land conservation programs. The northeast maple forest managed by private landowners has considerable conservation potential and provides habitat for diverse wildlife, including some endangered bird species. Although the benefits and challenges of landowners for enrollment in private land conservation programs have been widely studied, literature specific to maple syrup producers is limited. This thesis focuses specifically on understanding the benefits and challenges of private landowners (maple producers) regarding some of the potential programmatic changes in the Audubon Bird-Friendly Maple (BFM) program. The current BFM is a recognition program, managed internally by Audubon, and Audubon is considering transitioning it to a third-party certification model that could improve uniformity, consistency, and transparency as the program grows. For both chapters presented in this thesis, we interviewed private landowners enrolled in the BFM program in the northeastern United States. For the first chapter, we focused on understanding the anticipated benefits and challenges of producers if Audubon transitions the current program to a formal third-party certification model. Marketing opportunities, product differentiation, and potential to receive a premium price on maple products were major benefits identified by the landowners from the potential third-party certification. Similarly, financial challenges such as cost, administrative challenges (burdensome paperwork, audits), and programmatic challenges (complex program standards, monitoring, and inspections) were barriers to shifting the program to a certification scheme. For the second chapter, we interviewed maple producers to explore their interests in developing a birding trail site on their property, focusing on their anticipated benefits and challenges. Understanding producers' perspectives on allowing public access to private land could provide valuable information and fill the gap in current literature and practice. Landowners reported business benefits (increased sales, awareness of BFM products) and community benefits (public education, land stewardship) as potential advantages of allowing public access to their land. However, loss of privacy, accessibility, and liability concerns were major obstacles shared by the landowners when considering allowing public visitations. Findings obtained from this study offer valuable insights to Audubon for the BFM program's future planning and design. Understanding producers' perceptions offers recommendations for examining the likelihood and potential adoption of programmatic changes to the BFM program and other private land conservation programs in different places.

Description

Keywords

private lands, maple syrup, producers, benefits, challenges, willingness

Citation

Collections