Finding Meaning in Solidarity

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

TR Number

Date

2026-06-10

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Virginia Tech

Abstract

This paper argues that solidarity is always meaningful for those who participate in it, and that this meaning is a kind of value distinct from both instrumental and moral value. Contemporary accounts of solidarity typically assess its value in terms of the consequences it produces or the moral goods it instantiates. However, these accounts cannot adequately explain why participants often find value in solidarities which are neither instrumentally nor morally valuable. Drawing on Susan Wolf's account of meaning in life, I propose that solidarity is meaningful in virtue of the kind of identification it requires. To be in solidarity with others is to identify with them on the basis of a shared social property, where this property matters to participants in a robust way: it shapes how they act, how they see the world, and how they feel. I argue that this form of identification generates meaning, which has three dimensions: it enables individuals to make sense of their lives, gives them a sense of belonging, and provides a sense of direction and agency. This account explains why solidarity can be experienced as valuable even in the absence of good consequences or moral worth, including in cases where its aims are trivial or morally pernicious.

Description

Keywords

Solidarity, meaning, value, identification, instrumental, intersubjective, moral value

Citation

Collections