An analysis of soil color for field classification and organic carbon estimation

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

TR Number

Date

2026-06-22

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Virginia Tech

Abstract

Soil color can act as a proxy for numerous soil properties including soil organic carbon (SOC), drainage class, clay, oxidation state of manganese and iron, and mineralogy. U.S. Soil Taxonomy uses Munsell soil color, measured in whole number designations or "chips," in the classification of mollic and umbric epipedons. It was believed forest soils of the eastern United States dry out to a lighter color than grassland soils, so a maximum Munsell dry value (lightness) of < 5.5 for mollic epipedons was introduced to exclude mollic epipedons from forested regions. However, there is little data available which validates the dry color criteria. Furthermore, there are few studies exploring soil color-SOC relationships in understudied pedogenic contexts such as buried A horizons or across ecoregions. Consequently, this research investigates (1) color change upon drying in grasslands and forest soils, and (2) the relationship of these colors with SOC. Samples were collected from Great Plains (n = 86) and Eastern Temperate Forest soils (n = 127) of North America. Moist and dry color was measured using the Konica Minolta CR-410 Chroma Meter. Soil organic and inorganic carbon were determined using total combustion and back titration, respectively. Clay percentage was collected using a laser particle size analyzer. Soil color-SOC predictive models were constructed to analyze the effectiveness of soil color as a proxy for SOC in understudied pedogenic contexts. Results show that Eastern Temperate Forest soils increase in Munsell value by 1.54 color chips upon drying, compared to 1.19 color chips for Great Plains soils (p < 0.001). The current dry color criterion reveals a weak separation between the ecoregions (Youden's J statistic = 0.016, accuracy = 0.413). The optimal dry Munsell value for maximum separation of ecoregions is 4.28 (Youden's J statistic= 0.513, accuracy = 0.723). Predictive models estimated SOC with moderate accuracy across ecoregions (moist R² = 0.64; dry R² = 0.56), with predictions more reliable for Eastern Temperate Forest soils compared to Great Plains soils. Furthermore, predictive models estimated SOC with low-moderate accuracy across burial statuses (moist R² = 0.41; dry R² = 0.22), with predictions more reliable for surface horizons than buried A horizons. While significant, the observed color differences between ecoregions are too small to be used for field classification of mollic or umbric epipedons using a Munsell color book. Even though we attempted to collect them, no tested soils exceeded a dry Munsell value of 5.5, suggesting the dry color criterion should be removed from U.S. Soil Taxonomy. Findings from soil color-SOC relationships demonstrate that predictive models benefit from ecoregion-specific and burial-specific analysis, supporting the development of rapid, field-scale SOC assessment tools.

Description

Keywords

mollic epipedon, umbric epipedon, buried A horizons, soil organic carbon, forest soil, grassland soil, Mollisols, soil taxonomy

Citation

Collections