Is Value-at-Risk (VaR) a Fair Proxy for Market Risk Under Conditions of Market Leverage?

Files
etd.pdf (142.47 KB)
Downloads: 174
TR Number
Date
2000-12-14
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Virginia Tech
Abstract

Ex-post intraday market-risk extrema are compared with ex-ante standard RiskMetrics parametric Value-at-Risk (VaR) limits for three foreign currency futures markets (British Pound, Japanese Yen, Swiss Frank) to determine whether forecasted volatility of market returns based on settlement price data provides a valid proxy for short-term market risk independent of market leverage.

Intraday violations of ex-ante one-day VaR limits at the 95% confidence level should occur for less than 5% of market days. Violation frequencies for each of the markets tested are shown to occur well in excess of this 5% tolerance level: 9.54% for the British Pound, 7.09% for the Japanese Yen, and 7.79% for the Swiss Franc futures markets.

Thus, it is empirically demonstrated that VaR is a poor proxy for short-term market risk under conditions of market leverage.

Implications for managing (measuring, monitoring, controlling), reporting, and regulating financial market risk are discussed.

Description
Keywords
Capital Allocation Requirements, Market Risk, Leverage, Value-at-Risk, VaR, Internal Models Approach
Citation
Collections