An evaluation of timber harvest planning training on logging quality in the Virginia Piedmont

Abstract

Interest in BMP-related logger education and training has increased dramatically in recent years. Harvest planning is a critical component of forestry water quality BMPs. All states’ BMP manuals recommend written timber harvest plans, and several states require them by law. The objective of this study was to evaluate the impact of harvest planning training and the use of written timber harvest plans on BMP compliance, landowner satisfaction and weather-related downtime in the Virginia Piedmont. Nine randomly chosen loggers (study group) from the Virginia Piedmont participated in two days of intensive harvest planning field training. Nine additional loggers were randomly chosen as a control group. Study loggers prepared and followed written timber harvest plans for the 29 tracts they harvested during the 8-month study period immediately following the training. Study Group loggers outperformed Control Group loggers for mean BMP compliance (90% vs. 86%), mean landowner satisfaction (3.54/4.0 vs. 3.27/4.0), and mean weather-related downtime (10% vs. 13%). Absolute scores for all evaluation criteria for both groups were good, and differences, though statistically significant, were relatively small, leading to conclusions that:

• Loggers in the Virginia Piedmont are generally doing a good job.

• Loggers in the Virginia Piedmont are planning their operations, whether a written plan is required or not.

• Harvest planning training and written harvest plans can marginally improve BMP compliance, landowner satisfaction and weather-related downtime, even for loggers who are already performing well.