Influence of surface tension and concentration of a non-ionic surfactant on the barrier effectiveness of a microporous polypropylene fabric for pesticide protective clothing

This research evaluated the influence of concentration and surface tension (γ) of aqueous solutions of a non-ionic surfactant on the barrier effectiveness of a fabric containing microporous polypropylene (PP) film that may be used in pesticide protective clothing (PPC). Aqueous solutions of Triton® X-100, a non-ionic surfactant, at various concentrations were prepared, and the γ of each solution was determined. The immediate advancing contact angles (θ), made by a 5-μL drop of each test liquid on the test fabric, were measured.

Barrier effectiveness was evaluated from the capillary penetration, wicking, and wetting characteristics of the fabric using the surfactant solutions at various concentrations. Wetting characteristics were evaluated from the drop absorbency test, a modified Draves test, the spreading coefficient (S_c) values and, by inference, from a Zisman plot.

As surfactant concentration increased, γ decreased, and then remained relatively steady past the 0.0134 percent concentration level, the critical micelle concentration (CMC) of Triton® X-100. As Triton® X-100 concentration increased, θ decreased, even past the CMC. Results of the study indicate that, as surfactant concentration increases, the amount of capillary penetration and the wicking distance increase even past the CMC. The time for drop absorbency and the Draves wetting tests were very high (> 600 seconds) for all liquids below CMC. Beyond the CMC, drop absorbency times were significantly lower for solutions of 2.0 and 5.0 percent concentration, and the Draves wetting times were also significantly lower.

The values of the cos θ and the γ were used to calculate the S_c for each liquid. The calculated spreading coefficients indicate that the liquids at all concentrations did not spread (wet) on the micro-porous PP test fabric for the advancing θ measured within 10 seconds of placing the drop.

Results of the statistical analysis showed that surfactant concentration was a significant factor in determining the barrier effectiveness of the fabric tested. Even though γ remained relatively unchanged beyond the CMC of the surfactant, the inability of the test fabric to serve as an effective barrier against liquid penetration by capillary action, wicking, and wetting increased significantly. Surface energy terms, that are normally used to explain liquid transport and wetting phenomena, may not in themselves be sufficient to determine the effectiveness of a fabric for PPC, especially since concentration of the surfactant, a pesticide adjuvant, is a significant factor in determining the barrier effectiveness of PPC. Consideration must be made for the fact that very high concentrations of surfactants are routinely used in pesticide application.